This list will be updated as players are suggested.
Bold indicates that the card has been made.
- Daniel "Danny Dimes" Jones
- Marquise "Hollywood" Brown
- Kirk "Captain Kirk" Cousins
- Christian "Run CMC" McCaffrey
- Greg "Legatron/The Leg" Zuerlein
- Chase "Mapletron" Claypool
- Jerry "Judge" Jeudy
- Andy "Red Rifle" Dalton
- Jameis "Famous Jameis" Winston
- Bobby "Swagner/Swags" Wagner
- Robert "Bobby Trees" Woods
- Eli "Burnt Toast" Apple (They definitely wouldn't do this one but I'll include it anyway)
- Saquon "Quadzilla/Saquads" Barkley
- Josh "Winter Soldier/Bazooka" Allen
- DJ "Charknado" Chark
- Brock "Mr. Relevant" Purdy
- Teddy "Two Gloves" Bridgewater
- DK "Swolecalf" Metcalf
- Aaron "A-Rod" Rodgers
- Adrian "All Day" Peterson
- Isaiah "Unicorn" Simmons
- Julio "Waffle House/The Jet" Jones
- Chris "Stone Cold" Jones
- Trent "Silverback" Williams
- Dalvin "The Chef" Cook
- Xavier "Rhodes Closed" Rhodes
- Demarcus "D-Law/Tank" Lawrence
- Michael "Slant Man" Thomas
- Aaron "Terminator" Donald
- Alvin "AK41" Kamara
- Matthew "Red Sleeves" Judon
- Ja'Marr "Uno/On the Case" Chase
- Patrick "Pat P" Peterson
- Taysom "Mormon Missile" Hill
- Odell "OBJ" Beckham Jr
- Trevor "T-Law/Sunshine" Lawrence
- Micah "The Lion" Parsons
- Leighton "The Wolf Hunter" Vander Esch
- Jason "Batman" Kelce
- Devonta "Skinny Batman" Smith
- Quez "Speedy Batman" Watkins
- AJ "Swole Batman" Brown
- Randy "Fat Randy" Bullock
- Von "Closer/Chinese Dragon" Miller
- Russell "Mr. Unlimited" Wilson
- Brandon "Let Him Cook" Cooks
- Danielle "The Real Deal" Hunter
- Josey "The Outlaw" Jewel
- Rashard "Hollywood" Higgins
- Justin "J-Herbo" Herbert
- Quinn "The Gut" Meinerz
- Matt "Torpedo" Milano
- Amon-Ra "Sun God" St Brown
- Zadarius and Preston "Supersmith Bros" Smith
- Cordarrelle "Flash/Swiss Army Knife" Patterson
- Mac "Big Mac" Jones
- David "Chief" Njoku
- Adrian "Smash" Amos
- Kingsley "JJ" Enagbare
- Elgton "Big E" Jenkins
- Jaire "Ja Money" Alexander
- Jevon "Snowman" Holland
- Jaylen "Penguin" Waddle
- Xavien "X" Howard
- Boston "Giant Killer" Scott
- Gus "Bus" Edwards
- Brian "Spider-Man" Burns
- Cam "Superman" Newton
- Le'Veon "Juice" Bell
- George "NFL Youngboy" Pickens
- Mitch "Money Mitch" Trubitsky
- Leonard "Playoff Lenny" Fournette
- Davis "The Giraffe" Mills
- Justin "JJettas" Jefferson
- Josh "Flash" Gordon
- Jeremiah "The Joker" Owusu-Koramora
- Dexter "Sexy Dexy" Lawrence
- Kenneth “K9” Walker
- JC "Mr. Int" Jackson
