Started making these types of threads in Madden 23, I will be doing the same this year.
The major difference is I will be listing player items by BOTH team and program, unlike last year where they were only listed by program.
IF ANY MISTAKES ARE MADE OR IF I AM MISSING ANY PLAYERS, PLEASE LET ME KNOW
*Marks a player item that requires a token that is no longer obtainable in order to get an extra chemistry slot
†Marks a player item that must hit a certain overall to unlock an extra chemistry slot for either the team represented on the player item's card art, all the teams the player started a game for throughout their career, or any team
All Teams
- Eric Berry | S | 2x Chiefs at 80 OVR; 2x Any Team at 85 OVR | Team Captains†
- Channing Crowder | MLB | 2x Dolphins at 80 OVR; 2x Any Team at 85 OVR | Team Captains†
- Kevin Mawae | C | 2x Jets at 80 OVR; 2x Any Team at 85 OVR | Team Captains†
- Frank Gore | HB | 2x 49ers at 80 OVR; 2x Any Team at 85 OVR | Team Captains†
- Ronde Barber | CB | 2x Buccaneers at 80 OVR; 2x Any Team at 85 OVR | Team Captains†
- Jordan Reed | TE | 2x Commanders at 80 OVR; 2x Any Team at 85 OVR | Team Captains†
Arizona Cardinals
- 93 Greg Dortch | WR | 2x | Division Dynasty
- 92 Aeneas Williams | CB | 3x | Team Diamonds
- 88 Marquise Brown | WR | 2x | Division Dynasty
- 84 Paris Johnson Jr | RT | 2x | Rookie Premiere*
Atlanta Falcons
- 93 Jake Matthews | LT | 2x | Division Dynasty
- 92 Bill Fralic | RG | 3x | Team Diamonds
- 88 Calais Campbell | RE | 2x | Division Dynasty
- 84 Bijan Robinson | HB | 2x | Rookie Premiere*
Baltimore Ravens
- 96 Randall Cunningham | QB | 2x All Career Teams (Eagles, Vikings, Cowboys, Ravens) | AKA Crews
- 93 Travis Jones | DT | 2x | Division Dynasty
- 92 Anquan Boldin | WR | 3x | Team Diamonds
- 88 Odafe Oweh | ROLB | 2x | Division Dynasty
- 84 Zay Flowers | WR | 2x | Rookie Premiere*
Buffalo Bills
- 93 Reggie Gilliam | FB | 2x | Division Dynasty
- 92 Ruben Brown | LG | 3x | Team Diamonds
- 88 Dion Dawkins | LT | 2x | Division Dynasty
- 84 Dorian Williams | MLB | 2x | Rookie Premiere*
Carolina Panthers
- 93 Bryce Young | QB | 2x | Division Dynasty
- 92 Julius Peppers | LE | 3x | Team Diamonds
- 88 Bradley Bozeman | C | 2x | Division Dynasty
- 84 Jonathan Mingo | WR | 2x | Rookie Premiere*
Chicago Bears
- 96 Gale Sayers | HB | 2x All Career Teams (Bears) | AKA Crews
- 93 Nate Davis | RG | 2x | Division Dynasty
- 92 Alshon Jeffery | WR | 3x | Team Diamonds
- 88 Justin Jones | DT | 2x | Division Dynasty
- 84 Darnell Wright | RT | 2x | Rookie Premiere*
Cincinnati Bengals
- 93 Ted Karras | C | 2x | Division Dynasty
- 92 Geno Atkins | DT | 3x | Team Diamonds
- 88 Logan Wilson | ROLB | 2x | Division Dynasty
- 84 DJ Turner | CB | 2x | Rookie Premiere*
Cleveland Browns
- 93 Shelby Harris | DT | 2x | Division Dynasty
- 92 Joe Thomas | LT | 3x | Team Diamonds
- 88 David Njoku | TE | 2x | Division Dynasty
- 84 Dawand Jones | RT | 2x | Rookie Premiere*
Dallas Cowboys
- 96 Randall Cunningham | QB | 2x All Career Teams (Eagles, Vikings, Cowboys, Ravens) | AKA Crews
- 93 Osa Odighizuwa | DT | 2x | Division Dynasty
- 92 Chuck Howley | MLB | 3x | Team Diamonds
- 88 Leighton Vander Esch | MLB | 2x | Division Dynasty
- 84 Luke Schoonmaker | TE | 2x | Rookie Premiere*
Denver Broncos
- 93 Mike McGlinchey | RT | 2x | Division Dynasty
- 92 Julius Thomas | TE | 3x | Team Diamonds
- 88 Jerry Jeudy | WR | 2x | Division Dynasty
- 84 Marvin Mims Jr | WR | 2x | Rookie Premiere*
Detroit Lions
- 93 Jalen Reeves-Maybin | LOLB | 2x | Division Dynasty
- 92 Kevin Glover | C | 3x | Team Diamonds
- 88 Penei Sewell | RT | 2x | Division Dynasty
- 87 Aidan Hutchinson | LE | 2x | Rookie Premiere*
- 84 Jahmyr Gibbs | HB | 2x | Rookie Premiere*
Green Bay Packers
- 93 Elgton Jenkins | LG | 2x | Division Dynasty
- 92 Clay Matthews | LOLB | 3x | Team Diamonds
- 88 Christian Watson | WR | 2x | Division Dynasty
- 84 Lukas Van Ness | LOLB | 2x | Rookie Premiere*
Houston Texans
- 96 J.J. Watt | RE | 3x | Team Diamonds
- 93 Sheldon Rankins | DT | 2x | Division Dynasty
- 92 Mario Williams | LE | 3x | Team Diamonds
- 88 Jimmie Ward | SS | 2x | Division Dynasty
- 84 C.J. Stroud | QB | 2x | Rookie Premiere*
Indianapolis Colts
- 93 Samson Ebukam | RE | 2x | Division Dynasty
- 92 Reggie Wayne | WR | 3x | Team Diamonds
- 88 Julian Blackmon | SS | 2x | Division Dynasty
- 84 Julius Brents | CB | 2x | Rookie Premiere*
Jacksonville Jaguars
- 93 Roy Robertson-Harris | RE | 2x | Division Dynasty
- 92 Donovin Darius | SS | 3x | Team Diamonds
- 88 Zay Jones | WR | 2x | Division Dynasty
- 84 Brenton Strange | TE | 2x | Rookie Premiere*
Kansas City Chiefs
- 93 Donovan Smith | LT | 2x | Division Dynasty
- 92 Will Shields | RG | 3x | Team Diamonds
- 88 Isiah Pacheco | HB | 2x | Division Dynasty
- 86 Darrelle Revis | CB | 2x All Career Teams (Chiefs, Patriots, Jets, Buccaneers) when fully upgraded | Playoffs†
- 84 Rashee Rice | WR | 2x | Rookie Premiere*
- Eric Berry | S | 2x Chiefs at 80 OVR; 2x Any Team at 85 OVR | Team Captains†
Las Vegas Raiders
- 93 Daniel Carlson | K | 2x | Division Dynasty
- 92 Lincoln Kennedy | RT | 3x | Team Diamonds
- 88 Marcus Epps | FS | 2x | Division Dynasty
- 84 Tyree Wilson | ROLB | 2x | Rookie Premiere*
Los Angeles Chargers
- 93 Zion Johnson | LG| 2x | Division Dynasty
- 92 Phillip Rivers | QB | 3x | Team Diamonds
- 88 Gerald Everett | TE | 2x | Division Dynasty
- 84 Tuli Tuipulotu | LOLB | 2x | Rookie Premiere*
Los Angeles Rams
- 96 Todd Gurley | HB | 3x | Team Diamonds
- 93 Coleman Shelton | C | 2x | Division Dynasty
- 92 Ryan McNeil | CB | 3x | Team Diamonds
- 88 Kyren Williams | HB | 2x | Division Dynasty
- 84 Byron Young | LOLB | 2x | Rookie Premiere*
Miami Dolphins
- 93 Jason Sanders | K | 2x | Division Dynasty
- 92 Reshad Jones | FS | 3x | Team Diamonds
- 88 Emmanuel Ogbah | LE | 2x | Division Dynasty
- 84 Cam Smith | CB | 2x | Rookie Premiere*
- Channing Crowder | MLB | 2x Dolphins at 80 OVR; 2x Any Team at 85 OVR | Team Captains†
Minnesota Vikings
- 96 Randall Cunningham | QB | 2x All Career Teams (Eagles, Vikings, Cowboys, Ravens) | AKA Crews
- 93 Dalton Risner | LG | 2x | Division Dynasty
- 92 Fran Tarkenton | QB | 3x | Team Diamonds
- 88 Harrison Phillips | LE | 2x | Division Dynasty
- 84 Jay Ward | FS | 2x | Rookie Premiere*
New England Patriots
- 93 Cole Strange | LG | 2x | Division Dynasty
- 92 Logan Mankins | RG | 3x | Team Diamonds
- 88 Jabrill Peppers | FS | 2x | Division Dynasty
- 86 Darrelle Revis | CB | 2x All Career Teams (Chiefs, Patriots, Jets, Buccaneers) when fully upgraded | Playoffs†
- 84 Christian Gonzalez | CB | 2x | Rookie Premiere*
New Orleans Saints
- 93 Rashid Shaheed | WR | 2x | Division Dynasty
- 92 Jimmy Graham | TE | 3x | Team Diamonds
- 88 Tyrann Mathieu | FS | 2x | Division Dynasty
- 84 Bryan Bresee | DT | 2x | Rookie Premiere*
New York Giants
- 93 Evan Neal | RT | 2x | Division Dynasty
- 92 Terry Kinard | FS | 3x | Team Diamonds
- 88 Shane Lemieux | LG | 2x | Division Dynasty
- 84 John Michael Schmitz | C | 2x | Rookie Premiere*
New York Jets
- 93 Tony Adams | SS | 2x | Division Dynasty
- 92 Joe Klecko | DT | 3x | Team Diamonds
- 88 Laken Tomlinson | LG | 2x | Division Dynasty
- 86 Darrelle Revis | CB | 2x All Career Teams (Chiefs, Patriots, Jets, Buccaneers) when fully upgraded | Playoffs†
- 84 Will McDonald IV | RE | 2x | Rookie Premiere*
- Kevin Mawae | C | 2x Jets at 80 OVR; 2x Any Team at 85 OVR | Team Captains†
Philadelphia Eagles
- 96 Randall Cunningham | QB | 2x All Career Teams (Eagles, Vikings, Cowboys, Ravens) | AKA Crews
- 93 D'Andre Swift | HB | 2x | Division Dynasty
- 92 Troy Vincent | CB | 3x | Team Diamonds
- 88 James Bradberry IV | CB | 2x | Division Dynasty
- 84 Nolan Smith Jr | LOLB | 2x | Rookie Premiere*
Pittsburgh Steelers
- 93 Broderick Jones | RT | 2x | Division Dynasty
- 92 Le'Veon Bell | HB | 3x | Team Diamonds
- 88 Mason Cole | C | 2x | Division Dynasty
- 84 Darnell Washington | TE | 2x | Rookie Premiere*
San Francisco 49ers
- 93 Aaron Banks | LG | 2x | Division Dynasty
- 92 Merton Hanks | FS | 3x | Team Diamonds
- 88 Dre Greenlaw | ROLB | 2x | Division Dynasty
- 84 Ji'Ayir Brown | SS | 2x | Rookie Premiere*
- Frank Gore | HB | 2x 49ers at 80 OVR; 2x Any Team at 85 OVR | Team Captains†
Seattle Seahawks
- 93 Jason Myers | K | 2x | Division Dynasty
- 92 Steve Largent | WR | 3x | Team Diamonds
- 88 Jaxon Smith-Njigba | WR | 2x | Division Dynasty
- 84 Anthony Bradford | RG | 2x | Rookie Premiere*
Tampa Bay Buccaneers
- 93 Aaron Stinnie | LG | 2x | Division Dynasty
- 92 Doug Martin | HB | 3x | Team Diamonds
- 88 Ryan Neal | SS | 2x | Division Dynasty
- 86 Darrelle Revis | CB | 2x All Career Teams (Chiefs, Patriots, Jets, Buccaneers) when fully upgraded | Playoffs†
- 84 Yaya Diaby | LOLB | 2x | Rookie Premiere*
- Ronde Barber | CB | 2x Buccaneers at 80 OVR; 2x Any Team at 85 OVR | Team Captains†
Tennessee Titans
- 93 Azeez Al-Shaair | MLB | 2x | Division Dynasty
- 92 Keith Bulluck | ROLB | 3x | Team Diamonds
- 88 Jeffery Simmons | RE | 2x | Division Dynasty
- 84 Will Levis | QB | 2x | Rookie Premiere*
Washington Commanders
- 93 James Smith-Williams | LE | 2x | Division Dynasty
- 92 Brian Orakpo | ROLB | 3x | Team Diamonds
- 88 Cody Barton | MLB | 2x | Division Dynasty
- 84 Emmanuel Forbes | CB | 2x | Rookie Premiere*
- Jordan Reed | TE | 2x Commanders at 80 OVR; 2x Any Team at 85 OVR | Team Captains†