Most broken MUT player all time??

My argument is for AKA II Quadfather (MUT23). AJ Dillon.

He was so broken they had to nerf him in less than 1 week.

Freight Train that did not turn off, persistent (which required 2 TFL to deactivate) and Bruiser. I think at release that was all for 2 AP.  That card was ridiculous to play against. I couldn't afford him until after he was nerfed.

Most people are going to say NFL 100 Dickerson.

That's likely,  but there was not many players with secure tackle or tackle supreme when the Dillon card was released. 100 Dickerson is probably the broken king though.

NFL 100 Dickerson 

(Since it says MUT we can't include 04 Michael Vick sadly)

It was definitely Dickerson.

Honorable mention to 2019 MUT master Shazier, Finneran, Vick (multiple years)  Dre...One year it was Barry...QB Derrick Henry...Megatron had a few, so did Moss...Leon Sandcastle (Deion in I think 13) was insanely OP

MrAgentSochi said:

NFL 100 Dickerson 

(Since it says MUT we can't include 04 Michael Vick sadly)

^ This!!! 

And his sidekick Randy Moss  with "Double Me" from that same release could be irritating also!!! Half the people couldnt use that Moss correct, but when they could, it was annoying for sure...

MUTMaster OBJ takes my vote.  I grinded so fast for that card in 16.  Just throw a streak and hold Y.

I didn't play the year where Dickerson was OP, so take that for what its worth

My head says Dickerson 100, but my heart says M20 MUt Master Pat Tillman. Fumbles galore and a reminder that MUT used to allow you to grind for free cards that were at times top of the META.

Def 100 Eric Dickerson, I wish I could be original but I can’t he was insanely OP

04 Michael Vick, hands down. No one is even close. Modern day Bo Jackson tecmo bowl'ish.

In my experience. Its 100% M23 AKA New Class Quadfather. Pit persistent on him and once his x-factor is on it dont go off.

weplaythose said:

In my experience. Its 100% M23 AKA New Class Quadfather. Pit persistent on him and once his x-factor is on it dont go off.

Nah man, you have to go back further than that. There were way more dominant cards in earlier Maddens. Every run with Dickerson was like having that X factor on him plus his spin, juke, etc were faster than any card in years.

He would break like 10 tackles on every run, even when 3 guys had him at the same time. Go look at highlights on the web. 

Madden 20/50 Dickerson was absolutely nuts. Every run was basically a TD. 94 Vick was completely un-defendable. These cards were so dominant that they were banned from competitive Madden leagues

Martyr1968 said:

Nah man, you have to go back further than that. There were way more dominant cards in earlier Maddens. Every run with Dickerson was like having that X factor on him plus his spin, juke, etc were faster than any card in years.

He would break like 10 tackles on every run, even when 3 guys had him at the same time. Go look at highlights on the web. 

Madden 20/50 Dickerson was absolutely nuts. Every run was basically a TD. 94 Vick was completely un-defendable. These cards were so dominant that they were banned from competitive Madden leagues

I was speaking from my personal experience. I didn't get M20 until mid 2021 and only played it for a few months before I got M22, which was when I actually started trying in MUT. I heard the Eric Dickerson was about as OP as Meta Knight in Smash Bros Brawl though.

Dansker85 said:

Most people are going to say NFL 100 Dickerson.

Yupppp