Plaxico or Calvin Johnson?

sensicough said:

Plax 4 sure then.  Harrison is a monster on short and mid.  If that’s what you need I guess he’d be your guy

Yes, Harrison is an awesome slot WR for sure!

Plax

Calvin is better because of his AP situation for me

Everyone's arguments here are valid, but I value Short In Elite too much to pick Calvin over Plaxico. There's no point in breaking tackles if you're not getting the separation first to catch the ball.

Play just because he will be a great 2wr but doesn't have great ablities

Megatron

SlowAndSteady said:

Calvin has better attributes and better discounted abilities. Plaxico is faster but that’s pretty much it. I’m gonna stick with Megatron. If Plax drops down around 400k I might give him a try. His 91 played great with Matchup Nightmare.

Ima have to say that you just agg, cuz plax has 1 ap SIE and that is so much better with the amount of KOs running around in a higher level madden game.

Papabradyboi said:

Ima have to say that you just agg, cuz plax has 1 ap SIE and that is so much better with the amount of KOs running around in a higher level madden game.

This is funny, I rarely use AGG catches. I have Megatron at WR2 and he is my guy for deep routes with Deep In/Deep Out. I don’t throw the ball unless he has separation. If I throw the ball 100 times I use AGG catch probably less than 5 times. It’s always possession catch or RAC catch if I know I have some space.

Btw what routes are you running Plax on with SIE beating the KO’s?

SlowAndSteady said:

This is funny, I rarely use AGG catches. I have Megatron at WR2 and he is my guy for deep routes with Deep In/Deep Out. I don’t throw the ball unless he has separation. If I throw the ball 100 times I use AGG catch probably less than 5 times. It’s always possession catch or RAC catch if I know I have some space.

Btw what routes are you running Plax on with SIE beating the KO’s?

sorry man, with the community that this video game has, I expect everybody that doesn’t use SIE to use DOE and agg catch. Motion slants, whips, crossers, corners, and short post. If your not agging then you don’t really need DOE unless the route is making a deep and out.

Calvin prolly since he gets RT and DOE for 3 ap

Papabradyboi said:

sorry man, with the community that this video game has, I expect everybody that doesn’t use SIE to use DOE and agg catch. Motion slants, whips, crossers, corners, and short post. If your not agging then you don’t really need DOE unless the route is making a deep and out.

All good man. I have Herman Moore at WR1 with SIE on him for the slants, drags, crossers, and corners. I just like to have different options for different uses on offense. If I do get Plax soon I might actually put Matchup Nightmare on him. I was running that on his 91 and it lit up all the time. Dude got separation and caught everything even after his speed was very outdated.

SlowAndSteady said:

Calvin has better attributes and better discounted abilities. Plaxico is faster but that’s pretty much it. I’m gonna stick with Megatron. If Plax drops down around 400k I might give him a try. His 91 played great with Matchup Nightmare.

He’s a goat on a 50 Steelers chem team though

Mrgamer427 said:

He’s a goat on a 50 Steelers chem team though

I bet he is!

megatron cant beat 3 ap for short in elite / deep in n out elite