Megatron or Carmichael at CB?

Currently have Carmichael in the slot on my raiders TT. I run a man scheme and Carmichael constantly gets burned, thinking of switching to Megatron. Thoughts?

I actually sold Calvin, like Carmichael better

markie20 said:

I actually sold Calvin, like Carmichael better

Good to know, what scheme do you run? And do you use him in the slot?

honestly I haven't been able to catch anything over any of them but I rarely get open against charmichel and Calvin isn't that good

I started off with Calvin at CB, and he wasn't great... Moved him to FS and he did  a little bit better, but still not great. Put Carmichael at FS and he has played much better than Calvin at that position....

I’d use neither  in the slot for their height which is better on the outside. Haven’t used either, but both seem amazing and Carmichael has some great abilities with 1 AP for Tip Drill and Pick Artist.

heffitos said:

Good to know, what scheme do you run? And do you use him in the slot?

In moving him around between FS, slcb or cb1 . In man im putting him at the de spot

SebSeb88 said:

I’d use neither  in the slot for their height which is better on the outside. Haven’t used either, but both seem amazing and Carmichael has some great abilities with 1 AP for Tip Drill and Pick Artist.

Who should I use in the slot? I have 95 Charles Woodson, 94 Deion, 93 Haynes as well. I might quicksell Deion, he’s been playing horrible for me lately.

heffitos said:

Who should I use in the slot? I have 95 Charles Woodson, 94 Deion, 93 Haynes as well. I might quicksell Deion, he’s been playing horrible for me lately.

If you do keep Deion I’d put him there. He plays pretty well for me there. If you QS him  put Haynes in the slot.

SebSeb88 said:

If you do keep Deion I’d put him there. He plays pretty well for me there. If you QS him  put Haynes in the slot.

Thanks. Unfortunately, I have to get rid of one of my CBs for chem reasons. Which would you recommend? Either Deion or Haynes. Haynes plays great on the outside for me, but I also have Carmichael and Woodson.

heffitos said:

Thanks. Unfortunately, I have to get rid of one of my CBs for chem reasons. Which would you recommend? Either Deion or Haynes. Haynes plays great on the outside for me, but I also have Carmichael and Woodson.

Haven’t used Haynes, but Deion has played pretty well in the slot and not bad on the outside.

SebSeb88 said:

Haven’t used Haynes, but Deion has played pretty well in the slot and not bad on the outside.

Thanks, I’ll try them both out and see how they are.

heffitos said:

Thanks, I’ll try them both out and see how they are.

Anytime! Good luck

I have seen Carmichael just stand there picking his nose, scratching his butt and dancing around to some imaginary song while allowing WRs to just burn him up.  Calvin hasn’t done this once.  I’ve had as many INTs with Calvin as I have anyone ever in this game.  Suppose it depends on scheme but I’ve sold Carmichael twice and I’m scared to death to put him in my lineup again