I run a man scheme mostly where my FS is often in man ...my SS is more often in zone.
Lott always plays well and gets crusher and PA for 1 AP. Davis has great traits and gets PA also for 1 AP, same.for Peppers but Peppers plays ball in air "balanced' not aggressive.
I've been running Peppers as. My CPU controlled SubLB in nickel because he's got 94 man cvg w my strat card
Peppers for me, but Lott looks great. I‘m a fan of his in IRL and MUT.
I ran peppers at sub and loved him so much I never thought he’d move. I tested him at FS in my nickel zone scheme and he never made it back to sublb. He is so good at FS. I do run about 35-40% man as I’m transitioning back to it and Peppers is still one of my top playmakers
I probably like Peppers the best overall, he is also great corner in the dollar defence. Lott is probably the best for a man scheme because of the 2 ap inside shade
I took Lott as my freebie Legend. Underperformed there but has been pretty good at corner and backup SS.
Tried Taylor was quiet. A few plays but usually not heard or seen during a game. Maybe other team stayed away?
Sold Taylor and picked up Davis, several multi pick games and help gang tackle. Night and day better than Lott and Taylor for me.
I have Peppers on the DL, Bears theme for the most part.