Who is the best TOTY running back?

I wanna know who I should buy.

CMC is probably the best of the TOTY HBs but there are definitely better HBs out there you could get

CMC hands down .

Hines

PlasmaBeam5229 said:

Hines

Why do you think Hines? 

Poor traits, low accel and agility compared to CMC/others. If you have HRM on your QB his entire last bucket is useless. No one is putting playmaker on him for 2 AP (BTW his 96 card got it for 1 AP ). His abilities are just ok because of that last bucket.

Martyr1968 said:

Why do you think Hines? 

Poor traits, low accel and agility compared to CMC/others. If you have HRM on your QB his entire last bucket is useless. No one is putting playmaker on him for 2 AP (BTW his 96 card got it for 1 AP ). His abilities are just ok because of that last bucket.

Return man 0ap, 99 cod

both have 4ap joystick so I don’t care about that

PlasmaBeam5229 said:

Return man 0ap, 99 cod

both have 4ap joystick so I don’t care about that

OP was asking about HB not return man ..I mean, the Fridge gets Return man for 0 AP. Doesn't make him the best HB in the game. Najee also gets it for 0 AP. So do Cordarelle and Hester.

I don't think one stat (COD) makes him better than CMC, who has 97 COD himself. Agility, accel, abilities, break tackle, etc. all are important and all in favor of CMC.

Also, Hines has zero good traits other than covers the ball. Does not fight for extra yards, is not clutch, no high motor, no sideline catch (so less toe tap animations on sideline catches).  I really cannot see that one rating of COD making him the best TOTY HB.

i have cmc and i dont think hes much better than any of the other backs ive used

his stamina seems to drop ridiculously

Martyr1968 said:

OP was asking about HB not return man ..I mean, the Fridge gets Return man for 0 AP. Doesn't make him the best HB in the game. Najee also gets it for 0 AP. So do Cordarelle and Hester.

I don't think one stat (COD) makes him better than CMC, who has 97 COD himself. Agility, accel, abilities, break tackle, etc. all are important and all in favor of CMC.

Also, Hines has zero good traits other than covers the ball. Does not fight for extra yards, is not clutch, no high motor, no sideline catch (so less toe tap animations on sideline catches).  I really cannot see that one rating of COD making him the best TOTY HB.

Ok I get it but Im just not a mccaffrey fan I thought you could tell by my pfp

PlasmaBeam5229 said:

Ok I get it but Im just not a mccaffrey fan I thought you could tell by my pfp

I get it but when someone asks for the best card out of a group I try to tell them objectively even if I don't like the player. I hate Brady but if someone asked me who is better in the pocket, 99 Brady or   Danny dimes , or Elway, or Kurt, etc , even though I'm a Giants fan and I love Elway I'd still say Brady's card was better. Just say next time that you hate CMC LMAO

Martyr1968 said:

CMC is probably the best of the TOTY HBs but there are definitely better HBs out there you could get

Thanks imma get him

Martyr1968 said:

I get it but when someone asks for the best card out of a group I try to tell them objectively even if I don't like the player. I hate Brady but if someone asked me who is better in the pocket, 99 Brady or   Danny dimes , or Elway, or Kurt, etc , even though I'm a Giants fan and I love Elway I'd still say Brady's card was better. Just say next time that you hate CMC LMAO

Ok I’d rather have hines but sure you can think cmc is better I don’t care I’m just not a fan