Best all time qb (Not including Brady)

Last Post

Best all time qb (That isn’t Tom Brady)

Drew Brees
50%
Peyton Manning
50%
Aaron Rodgers
0%
Michael Vick
0%
Total votes: 2
Posts: 3 |
0
#1

if Tom Brady didn’t exist, who would be the best quarterback of all time?

Reply with quote Send DM Report
Posts: 2266 |
2,864
#2

Joe Montana

Reply with quote Send DM Report
Posts: 963 |
2,504
#3

What is Vick doing on this list?

Reply with quote Send DM Report
Posts: 3 |
0
#4
Gopats said:

What is Vick doing on this list?

He has that dog in him, everyone knows that by now. (And best elusive QB OAT)

Reply with quote Send DM Report
Posts: 3747 |
15.8K
#5

Mahomes?  This coming from a 49ers fanatic, breaks my heart to admit this, i wish i were coming here to try and convince you all that Joe Montana or Steve Young deserve to be on this list, sadly i think Patty Mahomes is already deserving of being in this conversation.  He just took down a VERY stout fEagles defense, on basically one leg.  Zero sacks.  Sure, O-line (and Andy Reid) deserve a ton of credit, as well, but come on...

Reply with quote Send DM Report
Posts: 3 |
0
#6

Trying to do more current times since current passing is more advanced and common

Reply with quote Send DM Report
Posts: 5 |
0
#7

Greg Dulchich

Reply with quote Send DM Report
Posts: 372 |
0
#8

Nathan Peterman… Come on now

Reply with quote Send DM Report
Posts: 784 |
2,815
#9

Johnny Unitas

Reply with quote Send DM Report
Posts: 12064 |
11.9K
#10

Manning, Brees, Montana

The three guys right under Brady

Below them are guys like Marino, Favre, Elway, Unitas, etc

Mahomes might be up there with those guys one day

Reply with quote Send DM Report
Posts: 4100 |
4,400
#11

Mariota

Reply with quote Send DM Report
Log in to join the conversation