Who’s better 98 Justin Herbert of 99 cam newton

I think cams better  also he’s a investment when rookie premere comes out he’s going up

Why would RP do anything for him? 

Herbert is cheaper, better release, and better ability count .

TheForumGuy said:

I think cams better  also he’s a investment when rookie premere comes out he’s going up

Your statement about him going up when Rookie Premiere comes out makes zero sense, but the real answer to your question is use who YOU like.  Why would you care what we think??

I'm a Chiefs fan, so I use Patrick Mahomes at QB.  There are those on here that would tell me that there are multiple QB's that are better than Mahomes, even though he is a Gold 99.  None of that matters to me.   From the comments I have read, people are very disappointed in the Cam Newton card, and people love the Herbert card.   The Game Changers promo were the last cards to get multiple 0 AP buckets, so Herbert can get better abilities for less AP.

TheForumGuy said:

I think cams better  also he’s a investment when rookie premere comes out he’s going up

Yeah bro RP wouldn't do anything for his price at all lol

TheForumGuy said:

I think cams better  also he’s a investment when rookie premere comes out he’s going up

Cam is one of the worst QB releases this year. 

Herbert is tall with an elite release and animates well. 

Dimebag Danny is better than both. 

Tebow will be the best QB until Madden 24.

Jaysonguy said:

Cam is one of the worst QB releases this year. 

Herbert is tall with an elite release and animates well. 

Dimebag Danny is better than both. 

Tebow will be the best QB until Madden 24.

i have to say mcnair over all those guys

Jaysonguy said:

Cam is one of the worst QB releases this year. 

Herbert is tall with an elite release and animates well. 

Dimebag Danny is better than both. 

Tebow will be the best QB until Madden 24.

I cant wait till that GT Perry. Hopefully we get a HB Faalele too

kaotikords said:

I cant wait till that GT Perry. Hopefully we get a HB Faalele too

Both cards will be incredibly fun.

Jfuertez said:

i have to say mcnair over all those guys

My dislike for that card started at its release.

Jaysonguy said:

My dislike for that card started at its release.

Lol why so? 

it might be a placebo for me because for releae and abilities, Herbert and McNair are the same as sfl and ple will be the same for since I don’t scramble 

but I for some reason jsut had way more success with McNair

Herbert

Jfuertez said:

Lol why so? 

it might be a placebo for me because for releae and abilities, Herbert and McNair are the same as sfl and ple will be the same for since I don’t scramble 

but I for some reason jsut had way more success with McNair

It's because he has poor medium accuracy and tends to float throws to the degree that I've never had one throw a TD on me closer than 20 yards because of that. 

I moved on to Tebow because he's a gorilla playing QB but I'm still a proponent of Dimebag Danny. 

Herbert is good because of his animations and while his middle game accuracy is atrocious he is beefed up on the short and deep. 

If a QB has to be shortchanged in accuracy I prefer it to be deep because there's a card for that.

Jaysonguy said:

It's because he has poor medium accuracy and tends to float throws to the degree that I've never had one throw a TD on me closer than 20 yards because of that. 

I moved on to Tebow because he's a gorilla playing QB but I'm still a proponent of Dimebag Danny. 

Herbert is good because of his animations and while his middle game accuracy is atrocious he is beefed up on the short and deep. 

If a QB has to be shortchanged in accuracy I prefer it to be deep because there's a card for that.

Interesting. 

I do agree Tebows player model is something else lol

but I have to disagree on your take on McNair, but it’s all personal preference, like I said, I had way more success with McNair taking me to 3 super bowls in less seasons than Herbert, but again theres too many variables of opponents and not playing as much h2h as before 

I haven’t tried danny but he looks like he’d fit for me exfelt for the ability stack at 4 for me instead Of 3.

A Rod