If Film Study lights up after someone spams one play, the offense shouldn’t be able to edit the play or call an audible or anything

Last Post
Posts: 810 |
1,338
#1

Otherwise, what’s the point in having the benefit of using your AP for that perk?

if you’re gonna spam one single play, deal with the consequences. It’s too easy to manipulate film study and use it against the defense, which is stupid.

Reply with quote Send DM Report
Moderator
Posts: 904 |
7,535
#2

Film study actually makes me spam plays more just to mess Auth people who use it lol.   I like running a variety of formations and plays but if I see film study, I'll purposefully trigger it just to troll.  I think it's a bad ability to use

Reply with quote Send DM Report
Posts: 5449 |
12.6K
#3

I think film study would be too powerful if it prevents the offense from changing anything. 

The most it should do is lead to your players defending the plays that activate it better

Also I never really got the hype for it in the first place. Even as someone who isn't very good at Madden I generally recognize plays being spammed fine.

Last edited by Breakluna - , edited 1 time in total.
Reply with quote Send DM Report
Posts: 756 |
195
#4

I love when it lights up after I spam stretch runs to the right over and over.  They run commit right and I flick left and hike at the last second and run free

Reply with quote Send DM Report
Posts: 810 |
1,338
#5
footballfan5654 said:

I love when it lights up after I spam stretch runs to the right over and over.  They run commit right and I flick left and hike at the last second and run free

This is my point exactly lol

Reply with quote Send DM Report
Posts: 3122 |
615
#6

You are explaining the EXACT reason why I don‘t waste my AP on Film Study.

Reply with quote Send DM Report
Posts: 810 |
1,338
#7
SlowAndSteady said:

You are explaining the EXACT reason why I don‘t waste my AP on Film Study.

But if they fixed it to the way I suggested, it would be worth using

Reply with quote Send DM Report
Posts: 3122 |
615
#8
WoodyWoody said:

But if they fixed it to the way I suggested, it would be worth using

Agree 100%

Reply with quote Send DM Report
Posts: 53 |
340
#9

That’s such a bad idea. How much help do you want?

The point of the ability is to get information. if you can’t do anything with that info, maybe spend the AP elsewhere?

Reply with quote Send DM Report
Posts: 810 |
1,338
#10
ngataproblem said:

That’s such a bad idea. How much help do you want?

The point of the ability is to get information. if you can’t do anything with that info, maybe spend the AP elsewhere?

relax tough guy

Reply with quote Send DM Report
Posts: 417 |
1,305
#11

I'm trying to experiment with the ability because it's so cheap, I might as just well, but I kind of agree with the fact of if somebody is spamming a play, you probably are going to be able to notice anyways without the ability.

Reply with quote Send DM Report
Posts: 6 |
100
#12

I you don't see how film study is a op ability... that's a skill issue

Reply with quote Send DM Report
Posts: 303 |
15
#13

I honestly dont care if they have film study cuz either way they will eventually figure out what ur runnign

Reply with quote Send DM Report
Posts: 53 |
340
#14
WoodyWoody said:

relax tough guy

Lol no one is being tough, it’s just a bad idea

Reply with quote Send DM Report
Posts: 1888 |
33
#15

No ability should harm the ability of a team to strategize. I don’t care how they buff the team with the ability but there Is no irl equivalent of being unable to audible because you’ve called a play before

Reply with quote Send DM Report
Log in to join the conversation