Id say 99 percent of "close" finishes near the sticks turn into inches when irl its the other way around. They NEVER fall forward or put the ball slightly out in this game (unless an equally goofy animation gets triggered for no good reason where you were CLEARLY stood up and stopped yet another defender becomes involved and the tangle of bodies defy the laws of physics and completely change direction and gain another 4 yards)
Does that "reach for it" ability help? I dont recall it ever doing anything but been a long time since i tried it.