Aikman or Warner?

which would you guys recommend for qb?

I think Aikman's the better option he's an LTD so he'll retain value better. Plus Aikman can use both HRM and SFL if you can activate his x-factor.

Just purchased Troy for 401k. Can definitely feel a difference between him and 89 Fields. Throws lasers between tight windows.

Also makes as a great rental.

did some short comparison on it here: https://www.mut.gg/forums/forum/mut-discussion-10/topic/quickly-comparing-kurt-warner-troy-aikman-34124/?post=265658#265658

Aikman best if you want hot route master, also needs gunslinger

StoicTrader said:

did some short comparison on it here: https://www.mut.gg/forums/forum/mut-discussion-10/topic/quickly-comparing-kurt-warner-troy-aikman-34124/?post=265658#265658

Aikman best if you want hot route master, also needs gunslinger

Great review, appreciate that insight and summary.  It's against my religion to run Cowgrrls on the MUT squad, but i would perhaps consider making an exception for GS, SFL + HRM X-factor, heh.

Quick (unrelated) question, how do you get your "last play" info to show up?  I understand the basics of how/where to find the in-game settings, but mine have not appeared ALL year.  Playing on PS5, i believe same platform as you were demonstrating.  For whatever reason, my last play information only shows up in Solo Battles, it has never worked in online H2H play.  I always assume EA is gonna EA, but then i clearly noticed this feature in your gameplay.  Thanks in advance, i don't actually expect you'll be able to directly answer my question, but i'm lost and confused, as per usual.  =)  Have fun, be safe.  Appreciate your detailed review on the current QB options.

peatrick said:

Great review, appreciate that insight and summary.  It's against my religion to run Cowgrrls on the MUT squad, but i would perhaps consider making an exception for GS, SFL + HRM X-factor, heh.

Quick (unrelated) question, how do you get your "last play" info to show up?  I understand the basics of how/where to find the in-game settings, but mine have not appeared ALL year.  Playing on PS5, i believe same platform as you were demonstrating.  For whatever reason, my last play information only shows up in Solo Battles, it has never worked in online H2H play.  I always assume EA is gonna EA, but then i clearly noticed this feature in your gameplay.  Thanks in advance, i don't actually expect you'll be able to directly answer my question, but i'm lost and confused, as per usual.  =)  Have fun, be safe.  Appreciate your detailed review on the current QB options.

If you play on All madden difficult you H2H such aa MUT champs or events the “Last play” box doesn’t show up but if you play on a lower difficulty in H2H seasons or solo battles, it will show the last play information.

I am going to disagree, Aikman has a horrible hitch in his release. I'd go Kurt.

Yooperman said:

If you play on All madden difficult you H2H such aa MUT champs or events the “Last play” box doesn’t show up but if you play on a lower difficulty in H2H seasons or solo battles, it will show the last play information.

THANK YOU, so very much for taking me to school on this.  I assume these are design / gameplay choices?  I do not recall things operating this way during `23, but i obviously know nothing.  Much obliged, kind sir.

peatrick said:

Great review, appreciate that insight and summary.  It's against my religion to run Cowgrrls on the MUT squad, but i would perhaps consider making an exception for GS, SFL + HRM X-factor, heh.

Quick (unrelated) question, how do you get your "last play" info to show up?  I understand the basics of how/where to find the in-game settings, but mine have not appeared ALL year.  Playing on PS5, i believe same platform as you were demonstrating.  For whatever reason, my last play information only shows up in Solo Battles, it has never worked in online H2H play.  I always assume EA is gonna EA, but then i clearly noticed this feature in your gameplay.  Thanks in advance, i don't actually expect you'll be able to directly answer my question, but i'm lost and confused, as per usual.  =)  Have fun, be safe.  Appreciate your detailed review on the current QB options.

preciate it - Aikman, Deion, Irvin all get passes from me since they were the last hall of fame great players that the Cowboys actually won with..

Also - Aikman has HRM as an ability which is what I was testing and what I use, the x factor is too difficult to activate IMO

Martyr1968 said:

I am going to disagree, Aikman has a horrible hitch in his release. I'd go Kurt.

that hitch is not noticeable to me with GS, I tested both, full gameplay with each one at that channel, to me it's obvious Aikman > but to each his own. strong arm trait makes noticeable difference

StoicTrader said:

preciate it - Aikman, Deion, Irvin all get passes from me since they were the last hall of fame great players that the Cowboys actually won with..

Oh, i somehow overlooked that aspect -- yes, of course the 49ers legend, Deion Prime Time Sanders is an exception, but he barely counts as dem `Boyz.  I have my own head-canon where i conveniently forget he played both places, heh.  Irvin looks pretty great, but i'd "settle" for Marvin Harrison, at a fraction (1/3rd) the cost if I were forced to choose right now.  Unfortunately, both remain out of reach, so no tough choices.

Thanks again, my dude.

peatrick said:

Oh, i somehow overlooked that aspect -- yes, of course the 49ers legend, Deion Prime Time Sanders is an exception, but he barely counts as dem `Boyz.  I have my own head-canon where i conveniently forget he played both places, heh.  Irvin looks pretty great, but i'd "settle" for Marvin Harrison, at a fraction (1/3rd) the cost if I were forced to choose right now.  Unfortunately, both remain out of reach, so no tough choices.

Thanks again, my dude.

👊

i'm enjoying Kurt and with the all madden strat his TP is 96. making all the throws