Best option

First I'm on Old Gen Xbox.

I am now one card away from completing my last player for team diamonds so I could have either the JJ Watt or the Todd Gurley card. I currently have all my tokens in JJ. The plan was take him and use him on my team. However seeing as we're getting 95 now and 96ers will be prevalent here in the next few days obviously the smart thing is to just sell him.

But my question is which one should I actually build and sell? I see there was a JJ card sold yesterday for 3.7 and there's two on the auction house now for about 3 to 3.2. but when I look at the gurly, there haven't been any sales in the last 7 days.. does anybody want that card or is nobody really buying it that's why everyone stopped making it and selling it?

Madisonmike said:

First I'm on Old Gen Xbox.

I am now one card away from completing my last player for team diamonds so I could have either the JJ Watt or the Todd Gurley card. I currently have all my tokens in JJ. The plan was take him and use him on my team. However seeing as we're getting 95 now and 96ers will be prevalent here in the next few days obviously the smart thing is to just sell him.

But my question is which one should I actually build and sell? I see there was a JJ card sold yesterday for 3.7 and there's two on the auction house now for about 3 to 3.2. but when I look at the gurly, there haven't been any sales in the last 7 days.. does anybody want that card or is nobody really buying it that's why everyone stopped making it and selling it?

People want halfbacks that are not only fast (even basic HBs get 96 SPD now), but also ones that come equipped with X-factor abilities that start ON, such as Peyton Hillis or King Henry, or Barry Sanders.

I don't know the old-gen Xbox market, but you're doing exactly what i would -- inspect those old sales.  If you happen to have the ONLY card available on the auction house, perhaps there's an opportunity to corner the market.  People are impatient and often pay whatever, although i suspect anyone that has ~3M coins to drop on a single player, probably knows enough to avoid that.

Honestly, with all the new X-factors, i think you might have missed your window of opportunity.  Neither of them are very good at the present moment.  Unstoppable Force X-factors are a thing again.

Oh I know neither one of them are great options. My intent was to use JJ on my team. But if I can get a couple million there's other options I can use. I just don't know which one I should put on the marketplace between JJ or Todd