Most overrated player on your fav team

vegaking300 said:

I've always liked the idea of people being realistic about the things they love. So the question is who do you guys think is the most overrated player on your fav team? Who's that guy that makes you roll your eyes when a fan of a different team says "oh but you guys have *random overrated player*, he's a beast!"

For me, it was Jaylon Smith, but since he's not on the team anymore I have to go with Michael Gallup. He's a really good player but he's kind of a one trick pony. He doesn't go over the middle, he has really weird drops at times, and he's not the best route runner. He's a good #2 but wouldn't be a good #1 like some people think

So I'm a panthers fan and it sucks when someone says Christian McCaffery is the best on the team or he is a top 2 running back but he is over rated, he gets injured way to much but if he can get to were he is healthy he would be a beasts.

Honestly tom brady, I know he won that one season for us but he's slow as shit and choked last year in the playoffs

niners probably trey lance - so many people think he is great but we really don’t know yet! Deebo at rb is another one. he’s great at both, and a top wr, but u can’t compare him to JT and other great rbs, it’s not really even close!

Well at this rate looks like you're gonna get a new owner and front office soon loll. Have you seen all the news about Washington breaking NFL rules?

As for this, I'm a niners and raiders fan. 

Niners: I'd say Arik Armstead tbh. They chose to pay him over Buckner which I still don't fully understand. Kittle could be up there just because of his injury issue.

Raiders: this is tough, but Waller, again, because of the injury issue. Besides Waller, I'd have to say their coach, McDaniels whatever it was. I think the last time he was a head coach he did a terrible job.

This one was hard for the raiders because they in general are such an underrated team, and they still kinda are.

hunt is under rated what are you talking about bro

LtPrism said:

Easily denzel ward, yes he might be a top 15 Cornerback. But that does not mean we should give him a 100 million dollar contract for 5 yeras, while a top 2 running back (nick Chubb) is being paid 24 million for 4 years.

denzel ward is a top 3-7 cb in the nfl. he locks up a-lot of Wr like chase and Jefferson and has great closing speed and awareness. for the contract, it may be a little much but getting a good, young, fast top 10 ( at least) on your team is crucial in the pass heavy game today and he is a great zone cb as well.

Monkey D. Luffy

XXX345897 said:

hunt is under rated what are you talking about bro

Monkey D. Luffy

Well my favorite team is the Saints and I would have to say the most overrated would have to be either Taysom Hill or Tre'Quan Smith even I doubt people even think he is good I just think he shouldn't have been resigned by us honestly.

Bucs fan.  It definitely used to be Gerald McCoy.  I would have to go with Lenny though.  I wanted to say Brady but his ability to make the team believe they can win and his IQ/work ethic are underrated.  Gronk without Brady would fit the bill too.

Panthers here and for sure its gotta be Robby Anderson. Guy hasn't even made a pro bowl and he acts like he's a top 5 receiver in the league when at most he's probably only a top 75 receiver

SanFranNiners80 said:

niners probably trey lance - so many people think he is great but we really don’t know yet! Deebo at rb is another one. he’s great at both, and a top wr, but u can’t compare him to JT and other great rbs, it’s not really even close!

I definitely think with Lance it's the potential. Dude has a great arm and great mobility with a good head on his shoulders. When it was unknown whether or not the cowboys would re-sign Dak, I actually wanted Trey Lance.

von11 said:

Vikings: Anthony Barr and Hendricks...can make an argument for Adam as well.  Most underrated...Cousins.  Now...I like Barr, Hendricks and Adam a ton...and don't like Cousins at all (I'm apparently part of the problem).

Adam Thielen isn’t overrated, in the Vikings fan base he is talked about a lot but in the entirety of the NFL he is overlooked so he’s underrated