Ranking Madden 24

X484SrVive said:

Id give it a good 8 I don’t think it’s fair to take off points for so many abilities being on the field cuz it’s legit June lol

Same bro, 😭 I don’t get why everyone is complaining like your team has the same Knockouts

I feel like this wasn’t the best madden but is was solid I had a lot of fun at points In the year and also had some boring parts. All in all I think it was better than 23. So a solid 7/10.

Game up Until 91s is always like a 8/10 but they then have to keep it up which is a 50/50 every year

JuanT said:

Feel like remix Madden 20 gameplay good Madden

Yes the thing that ruined it was every promo having x-factors after the Super Bowl and knockouts being constant

9/10

I love playin.  I’m on old gen so I suppose there’s less op abilities and X-factors which is great, i’ll stay old gen

Justin_Time18 said:

Game play -6/10

pack odds-2.5/10

Card art- 7/10

promos- 8.5/10

abilitys- 3/10

everything else- 7/10

overall rating - 5.7/10

Card art gets a 3/10 solely Because Ultimate legends. Great cards but horrible card art, I honestly thought they were going to get better as they released. Big miss especially since there the best cards in the game.

10/10, I've had a blast. But if they take out AH in 2025 I'm not buying.

Honestly worst madden, pack luck is ass and abilities are just so OP it’s dumb as hell. Only plus is there’s a lot of content.

7/10, 2nd best since madden 20

touchdownking said:

Idk about you, but I have actually had a lot of fun playing madden 24 this year. How does this madden rank with other maddens in the past?

8/10.  It’s not perfect but it’s fun. Deep zone KO and the juke move need adjusting.  Packs odds are bad.  BND don’t like.  If we Earned BNDs should be allowed towards sets being completed.  Season rewards need to be better.  By the time the reward is earned its value is minimal.

I say it's only above Madden 19 in the overall experience, packs odds are so bad that the opportunity packs are the only way to pull them with reasonable odds, gameplay is suspiciously random that accusation of DDA being in game is a big topic, AI is so dumb that you have to user flat zones just so a kid don't beat you with corner routes repeatedly, abilities like vanguard and angry runs made the game more P2W than any other Madden, and while promos are good, there's so little of them that I can go a week without playing and haven't missed much beside ULs and other weekly promos that was bad for a good bit, servers are constantly down when a big promo is out, framerate are slow, game breaking glitches haven't been patched despite them being in the game since day 1, desync glitchers still get away with cheating, EA is as secretive as the CIA, have zero transparency, and other game modes are ignored and highly neglected

touchdownking said:

Same bro, 😭 I don’t get why everyone is complaining like your team has the same Knockouts

lol nah abilities lower skill gap.....game is so bad you can send 2 or 3 with pre lits and if you do get beat kos are there to bail you out.....EASILY the lowest skilled madden ive ever played

Game play has been what it is the past few years with abilities and x-factors.

What's really changed this year is pack odds and team building. I don't even know how this is a debate. 

I've played for the past seven years, or so, with a strict theme team and this is the first time this late in the year I couldn't afford anything I wanted without spending money. In past years, I could always count on winning enough in Weekend League or even Solo Battles when there were levels, so I could accumulate enough coin by December/January to afford eveything comfortably. Packs were bad last year, but this year they really fell off of a cliff. It's actually comical how little value comes out of every single pack. Limiteds are also out of control. Again, it's actually an eye-rolling laugh.

I played till late last year, and we had the same general experience with pre-lits. Whatever. That's how they're 'differentiating' stars, supposedly.

I won't be buying next year's game until I've seen early reviews, and/or Weekend League (or some other type of good reward gameplay) is reinstated.

i would say pretty solid overall. my only not too favorite parts about this years MUT was the 50/50 packs, even though i found myself beating the odds more times than not, and later in the year how some people have like 3 vanguards and an angry runs and only run stretches. but other than that, i’d give the game a good 7.5-8/10