Jamal Charles or Marshon Lynch

I bought Jamal, used him, sold him bought Lynch and can’t decide which one was better

touchdownking said:

I bought Jamal, used him, sold him bought Lynch and can’t decide which one was better

I haven't used Lynch, but he's quite possibly one of the better HBs in the entire game.  I moved on from Jamaal Charles, using Shaun Alexander at the moment, but overpaying for his ability stack, something liek 4-5AP and reconfigured my squad to have 25/50 Seahawks in order to get him to max 99 SPD (also Legion of Boom, using OBJ et al).

IMO, Shaun is nearly as shifty a runner as Jamaal Charles, but way more physical.  Jamaal just moves so well on the field, but the taller RBs tend to get better juke animations, longer legs or something.  For the time being, i prefer having both Truzz and built on Angry Runs, along with Tank and Jukebox, of course, hence Shaun.  We have so much AP now, it hardly matters to waste a bunch on a single player.

I am sticking with JC for the 0 AP omegastack, adding on FT XF for some additional juice. I’ve tried Payton and Shaun but sold back as I played just as well with JC, no fumble issues at all either.

Was using Lynch at HB1 and Powerback and Charles at 3rd Down Back it was a decent setup but too much coins invested to that setup so I sold lynch and bought Perry. Charles HB1 and 3rd Down Back And William Perry Power back.

Jhays45 said:

Was using Lynch at HB1 and Powerback and Charles at 3rd Down Back it was a decent setup but too much coins invested to that setup so I sold lynch and bought Perry. Charles HB1 and 3rd Down Back And William Perry Power back.

Nice

peatrick said:

I haven't used Lynch, but he's quite possibly one of the better HBs in the entire game.  I moved on from Jamaal Charles, using Shaun Alexander at the moment, but overpaying for his ability stack, something liek 4-5AP and reconfigured my squad to have 25/50 Seahawks in order to get him to max 99 SPD (also Legion of Boom, using OBJ et al).

IMO, Shaun is nearly as shifty a runner as Jamaal Charles, but way more physical.  Jamaal just moves so well on the field, but the taller RBs tend to get better juke animations, longer legs or something.  For the time being, i prefer having both Truzz and built on Angry Runs, along with Tank and Jukebox, of course, hence Shaun.  We have so much AP now, it hardly matters to waste a bunch on a single player.

Shaun is shiftier than jc?

rompcrew3601 said:

Shaun is shiftier than jc?

Nah, but close. I think I said "nearly as shifty" Jamaal quite possibly the best pure runner I've used all year, sadly FOF not that great. Poor phrasing, my bad.

Curious how that new Thurman Thomas plays, but not enough to build his set. Content with Shaun. Although Truzz might be a bit overrated. Needed help against Avalanche, so pairing Truzz with Tank.

peatrick said:

Nah, but close. I think I said "nearly as shifty" Jamaal quite possibly the best pure runner I've used all year, sadly FOF not that great. Poor phrasing, my bad.

Curious how that new Thurman Thomas plays, but not enough to build his set. Content with Shaun. Although Truzz might be a bit overrated. Needed help against Avalanche, so pairing Truzz with Tank.

Yea man,im thinking about Thurman,he impressed me in his solo challenge and i can sale back charles for a little extra coin.