RP/UA makegood should be a BND Redux of our choice

Posts: 62 |

180

This seems like a perfect solution to me. The Redux cards already exist and their overalls are in line with current champions. If EA were to give us our choice of any one, or even two, BND Redux cards, I would be perfectly content with that.

Posts: 1536 |

705

Stevenam81 said:

This seems like a perfect solution to me. The Redux cards already exist and their overalls are in line with current champions. If EA were to give us our choice of any one, or even two, BND Redux cards, I would be perfectly content with that.

I’m always for higher ovr BND cards myself

Posts: 345 |

5,069

That’s actually a good idea

Posts: 2514 |

1,828

Stevenam81 said:

This seems like a perfect solution to me. The Redux cards already exist and their overalls are in line with current champions. If EA were to give us our choice of any one, or even two, BND Redux cards, I would be perfectly content with that.

I'd love this, but IF we get anything, it'll be like 1 bnd 80+ pack with a 10% chance at an 82

Posts: 109 |

1,850

weplaythose said:

I'd love this, but IF we get anything, it'll be like 1 bnd 80+ pack with a 10% chance at an 82

This is exactly what will happen lmao. Any hope of EA actually giving us a good make right is delusional.

Posts: 62 |

180

weplaythose said:

I'd love this, but IF we get anything, it'll be like 1 bnd 80+ pack with a 10% chance at an 82

Unfortunately, what we get will probably be closer to that. That's why I'm saying a BND Redux "should" be the makegood. The fact that I would find that acceptable tells me that it's not likely. Just wanted to throw this idea out there in case EA sees it and hasn't decided on what they intend to give us yet.

Posts: 2514 |

1,828

Stevenam81 said:

Unfortunately, what we get will probably be closer to that. That's why I'm saying a BND Redux "should" be the makegood. The fact that I would find that acceptable tells me that it's not likely. Just wanted to throw this idea out there in case EA sees it and hasn't decided on what they intend to give us yet.

I 100% agree that your suggestion is a good idea. I wish it would happen but it won't. EA unfortunately won't give everyone what is probably a $25 pack for free. I remember even a few years ago in Madden 23 when makerights we actually good. Remember when they gave everyone a 95-96 LTD fantasy pack for the lockout glitch, or gave everyone a bnd 96 gravedigger for 88+ AKA rerolls being messed up?

Posts: 62 |

180

weplaythose said:

I 100% agree that your suggestion is a good idea. I wish it would happen but it won't. EA unfortunately won't give everyone what is probably a $25 pack for free. I remember even a few years ago in Madden 23 when makerights we actually good. Remember when they gave everyone a 95-96 LTD fantasy pack for the lockout glitch, or gave everyone a bnd 96 gravedigger for 88+ AKA rerolls being messed up?

Whatever it is, I hope it's a static reward that is equal for everyone. A makegood should not involve luck or chance. For this type of situation, it's not cool when the makegood is an 87 for some people, but only an 83 for others. That's ok when a certain card wasn't in packs so they give people replacement packs to compensate. In this case, we were told we would get champion level rewards and by the time they delivered, they were not. That is what the goal of the makegood should be so I'm really hoping we get an 87/88. This is what made me think of the Redux cards. The cards aren't brand new and have already been in the game for a while. EA has already made a lot of money from the LTD versions and their time in the sun is over. They are comparable to current champions and it would most likely please everyone who can be pleased.

Posts: 2514 |

1,828

Stevenam81 said:

Whatever it is, I hope it's a static reward that is equal for everyone. A makegood should not involve luck or chance. For this type of situation, it's not cool when the makegood is an 87 for some people, but only an 83 for others. That's ok when a certain card wasn't in packs so they give people replacement packs to compensate. In this case, we were told we would get champion level rewards and by the time they delivered, they were not. That is what the goal of the makegood should be so I'm really hoping we get an 87/88. This is what made me think of the Redux cards. The cards aren't brand new and have already been in the game for a while. EA has already made a lot of money from the LTD versions and their time in the sun is over. They are comparable to current champions and it would most likely please everyone who can be pleased.

I think this is completely reasonable.

Posts: 2071 |

#10

Still waiting on missing ua players gl with makerights

Posts: 184 |

2,907

#11

would be nice ngl

Posts: 1365 |

2,935

#12

weplaythose said:

I'd love this, but IF we get anything, it'll be like 1 bnd 80+ pack with a 10% chance at an 82

Ding ding ding

Posts: 463 |

1,030

#13

They make good on a mistake and you just ask for more? Seriously? Take what they offer

Posts: 2 |

300

#14

Yes

Posts: 2 |

300

#15

OBIDOBI said:

They make good on a mistake and you just ask for more? Seriously? Take what they offer

What make good? Lmao. I’ve been waiting for my UA and rookie premiers since pre order + 2nd week of the game, i didn’t even get my pre order rewards from the deluxe edition. Whatever make right they do, they better be giving us cards that aren’t out dated already like the UA and RP.

1 2