It's time to settle this

Random question but how do I convince my mom to give my Xbox back

Steele said:

Brady no question. Mahomes isn't even top 5 all time

I don't even know if I'd put Mahomes in my top ten. My list (relative to the era they played in) is probably something like

Tom Brady

Peyton Manning

Johnny Unitas

Joe Montana

Dan Marino

Drew Brees

Brett Favre

Andrew Luck

Aaron Rodgers

Eli Manning 

Honorable mentions to Ken Anderson, Phillip Rivers, Matthew Stafford, Jim Kelly, Roger Staubach, Bobby Layne, Dan Fouts.

cool

Zslash said:

Random question but how do I convince my mom to give my Xbox back

Please don't spam. This thread is about QBs.

sorry

Marino.

weplaythose said:

I don't even know if I'd put Mahomes in my top ten. My list (relative to the era they played in) is probably something like

Tom Brady

Peyton Manning

Johnny Unitas

Joe Montana

Dan Marino

Drew Brees

Brett Favre

Andrew Luck

Aaron Rodgers

Eli Manning 

Honorable mentions to Ken Anderson, Phillip Rivers, Matthew Stafford, Jim Kelly, Roger Staubach, Bobby Layne, Dan Fouts.

Wouldn't put Mahomes yet puts Andrew Luck. You can't make this shit up LMAO

hey Luck was pretty good

Brady until Mahomes plays 20 years and wins 7 + and go to 10+ SBs.

OPJ98 said:

Wouldn't put Mahomes yet puts Andrew Luck. You can't make this shit up LMAO

I most definitely am not. I would take Luck over Peyton Manning, I believe Luck was a better player on worse teams. Outisde of TY Hilton, Luck had almost no supporting cast, offensive line, or defense, yet he put those Colts teams on his back year in and year out. Mahomes has had everything handed to him on a silver platter every since he became a starter. The fact of the matter is, Mahomes has the maybe the best QB coach ever, an all-star lineup for most of his career, and refs that cater to him. If you watch some of these hits like the one that the Jets put on Murray last sunday, everyone knows that no one is alowwed to do that to Mahomes. Even the announces can't shut up about him, I'm tired of watching Colts games and Cris Collinsworth can't shut up about how great Mahomes it. There is probably 5 or 6 QBs in the league right now that are better than him.

Agabs2169 said:

Brady until Mahomes plays 20 years and wins 7 + and go to 10+ SBs.

facts. Unless Mahomes lasts as long at the level and success Brady did, there isn't even a debate to be had.

Tom played in 10 superbowls, won 7.

Both losses to the Giants were on the Defense, or else he would have 9 wins!!!

I can't stand Brady, but he's ahead of Mahomes by a large margin.

Zslash said:

But the real GOAT is Troy Aikman (not biased) lol

Very biased

Mahomes clears