89 Montana,88 Trevor,87 Mariota and 87 Tebow. Rank these QB's.

Posts: 1003 |

3,433

Those are my QB's after pulling Montana from the BND All madden pack. Ive been using Mariota and he's played well and having 88 Trevor as the backup. I do run a 49ers TT but am at only 13/50 so its not a priority right now. I'll probably just keep using Mariota especially since I'll be using his BND card from doing Crabtree set and keep Montana as a back up for now unless Mariota struggles. I was hoping for anyone but Montana to be honest 😆 but he doesn't look bad and he gets some decent abilities for now. They are all good qbs. I've only played 2 solos with Tebow but usually prefer right handed qbs.

I would rank them 1-Mariota

2-Montana

3-Tebow

4-Trevor

Posts: 515 |

440

Trevor is the best imo

Posts: 5595 |

Mariota is currently the best qb, rushing and throwing wise. Second could be either Montana or Lawrence, both are good pocket QBs but Montana has better pocket passing stats and Lawrence is more mobile. Tebow is 4th, simply because his throwing stats are nerfed and his release is bad. Still a great Qb for designed runs though.

Posts: 636 |

103

In my opinion:

1. Mariota
2. TLaw
3. Montana
4. Tebow

I, personally, like TLaw more than Mariota, but Mariota's speed gives him the edge as an overall complete QB. Tebow is fun if you like running with your QB a lot, but if you pass a lot, he's definitely the worst. I haven't personally used Montana, but he looks like he'd be great as a pocket passer, but his lack of mobility puts him below TLaw.

Last edited by Gent - , edited 1 time in total.

Posts: 10298 |

5,551

Gent said:

In my opinion:

1. Mariota
2. TLaw
3. Montana
4. Tebow

I, personally, like TLaw more than Mariota, but Mariota's speed gives him the edge as an overall complete QB. Tebow is fun if you like running with your QB a lot, but if you pass a lot, he's definitely the worst. I haven't personally used Montana, but he looks like he'd be great as a pocket passer, but his lack of mobility puts him below TLaw.

I would agree with this.

Posts: 12064 |

11.9K

Gent said:

In my opinion:

1. Mariota
2. TLaw
3. Montana
4. Tebow

I, personally, like TLaw more than Mariota, but Mariota's speed gives him the edge as an overall complete QB. Tebow is fun if you like running with your QB a lot, but if you pass a lot, he's definitely the worst. I haven't personally used Montana, but he looks like he'd be great as a pocket passer, but his lack of mobility puts him below TLaw.

I agree with this as well, very well said.

Posts: 684 |

1,021

1. T-Law- decent speed good stats 87 TUP along with quick draw gives you the ability to beat the blitz cheesers and know the ball is going to be accurate more often than not.

2. Mariota- Almost as good as T-law more speed trades off for less DAC & TUP. On a TT like I have it's hard to sit him.

3. Montana- Criminally low TUP stat & lack of mobility kills the card for me.

4. Tebow- Throwing stats and 80 TUP make it a liability as a passer. But his speed,agility and 86 carry make him the best read option QB in the game ATM.

In this game I believe throw under pressure (TUP) is the most important stat on a QB card with blitz cheesers around every corner if the card has a weak TUP stat you don't even have to get sacks with the blitz because the pressure generated causes errant inaccurate throws which lead to interceptions & bad throws.

Last edited by Copen - , edited 4 times in total.