MUT card Mount Rushmore.

Madden 20 NFL 100 Dickerson

Madden 20 NFL 100 Randy Moss

Madden 20 Zero Chill 95 Sean Taylor

Madden 20 Zero Chill 93 Ted Hendricks

91 OVR Flashback Vick 2016

99 MUT Champion Kam 2022

Any Barry Sanders Thanksgiving card

99 LOLB Sean Taylor 2017

Madden 20 GT Bo Jackson

Madden 22 OOP Derrick Henry

Madden 22 BB Peyton Manning

Madden 20 Draft Cam Newton

Deion Sanders every year, mut15 Bo Jackson, mut 22 QB Henry and mut20 Eric Dickerson pre patch.

97 overall Playoff Deion Sanders in MUT 18, 99 overall Positional Hero Julio Jones in MUT 16, MUT Master Sean Taylor in MUT 18, and 97 (?) overall TOTW Ryan Shazier in MUT 16.

This is a really great idea for a thread, by the way!

In no particular order ofc

Derrick Henry's 96 qb card last year (easily the best qb i've ever played with) 

Calvin Johnson fully pu'd to a gold 99 in 20 (that card was amazing for me)

Taylor Mays' GT in 20

David Boston in 21 (dolphins TT really made him special)

HMs:

Any DeVante Parker LTD (bro got one in three straight years lmao)

Any Bmarsh card (he agg'd everyone and was a stud on my TT)

Any Jevon Holland card (even his core rookie card last year, I usered it for like a month or two lol)

madden 20 NFL 100 Eric Dickerson

madden 20 GT Michael Vick

madden 20 NFL 100 Randy Moss

madden 18 summer block buster Odell Beckham Jr.

Bawl9455 said:

Madden 20 NFL 100 Dickerson

Madden 20 NFL 100 Randy Moss

Madden 20 Zero Chill 95 Sean Taylor

Madden 20 Zero Chill 93 Ted Hendricks

this list is elite

1. Eric Dickerson - MUT 20, NFL 100 | X-Factor... absolutely overpowered and fun. 

2. M15 GT Taylor Mays... could fly around and hitstick the absolute f outta people. 

3. Barry Sanders's Easter card  and Randy Moss's 95 X-factor in the same year (Madden 20)

4. Pat Tilman (99 Mut Master Madden 20).

started playing mut in 22 so 94 dj moore gridiron guardians (m22), 99 kyler Murray ltd (m22), 99 Tyreek hill gt (m22), and 91 Larry csonka  team captain (m23)

Taylor Mays - M20 Golden Ticket

Fridge - M22 Golden Ticket FB card

Bo Jackson - M20 Golden Ticket

Sean Taylor - M19 (either 18 or 19) MUT Master

99 power up Cunningham (20) 97 power up Kyler Murray (20) 97 NFL honor Michael “slant man” Thomas                                                          89 DK Metcalf (21) (remember when he was best card in game?)

WSoldi said:

Mut 20 Eric Dickerson NFL 100 94OVR: Steamrolled defenders with his active X factor freight train. One of the most OP mut cards in recent history. This card shot Dickerson's mut stock way up. Clearly was the best NFL 100 promo card, and many people used him. They did fix his X factor but not until I found a new love for Mut online H2H using him after being a mostly solo player for years. 

Mut 17 Mike Vick Career Tribute Limited Time 97OVR: This was the first really expensive card me and my buddy bought during our first mut. We pooled our coins back when you could kinda do that and switched off H2H using Vick. It was so fun capturing tons of sick clips of Vick throwing rockets on the run or evading the whole defense for a rushing td. This was my first mut Vick experience and man was it memorable. If you missed this card you missed out bad. 

Mut 18 Earl Campbell Boss Battles Boss 99OVR: This was a cool promo for endgame players. It was not easy and took a lot of grinding to choose between 99 rated Dwight Clark, Earl Campbell, Ed Too Tall, and Rickey Jackson. Once you finally got your Boss you were pumped. Most preferred the defense Bosses but I had so much fun running Earl for the end half of mut 18. I haven't played with another running back OP like him except Dickerson mut 20. Just an absurdly fun card and thats what muts about. 

Multiple Muts Tom Brady Super Bowl MVP 99OVR: How could you not include the GOAT? He's been the 99 overall SB MVP in a few years of mut but I did the MVP set in advance of SB 51 knowing my Patriots were probably going to be in it, and after going to and seeing the Pats win the AFC Championship against the Steelers. We all know how SB 51 went down, but needless to say that 99 OVR Tom SB 51 MVP was god tier. Just having him on your team was enough to feel like you could win every game in any scenario. His stats were absurd for throwing accuracy, his speed sucked but using Tom is always fun in Mut. I still think that this was Tom's best mut card of all time, mostly because of his performance in SB 51 and how that translated into the card's stats was just so boss as a Pats fan. This card was cooler and better than his GOAT edition, fake retirement tributes, and the campaign Tom in like 17 or 18? Best card art also on a Tom card. Change my mind.

Thats a real solid list man, great post.

I think people underestimate those 99 Brady cards that come out at times. While he’s not the typical Meta QB when we look at the Vick/Hurts/Cunningham capable cards, every so often Brady’s top card just has that vibe going on where as long as the user has a decent line, that Brady card is slinging that ball to receivers just about as fast as any hyped-Aaron Rodgers type card could have.