Agree Or Disagree - #1: Top 10 AKA New Class Players In Madden 23

Starting a new weekly thread series. The MUT.GG staff releases a Top 10 Player Item Rankings every Friday. Each week we’ll look at each list and members of the community and myself will state whether they agree or disagree with the list (I doubt many would rank them the exact same way but you never know), and what we would change (if we would change anything).

MUT.GG’s Rankings:

1. 98 OVR Gus The Bus (Gus Edwards; HB)

2. 98 OVR Flash (Cordarrelle Patterson; HB)

3. 96 OVR Quadfather (A.J. Dillon; HB)

4. 98 OVR Groot (Greg Rousseau; LE)

5. 98 OVR Furious George (George Karlaftis; LE)

6. 98 OVR Maniac (Shaquille Leonard; LOLB)

7. 96 OVR Red Tornado (Ryan Jensen; C)

8. 97 OVR Hit Man (Harrison Smith; SS)

9. 98 OVR Legatron (Greg Zurrlein; K)

10. 97 OVR The Terror (Terron Armstead; LT)

Agree Or Disagree?:

Disagree

What I Would Change:

In my opinion, this is one of the better rankings we have seen so far, but there are some things that I would change. 

First off, I would move Quadfather down to six, while moving Groot, Furious George, and Maniac up one spot each. Although he was completely broken when he first came out, he is no where near that level now. He can easily be stopped with the right defensive formations, and if you have players that can equip Secure Tackler or Tackle Supreme, they will have a much better chance of stopping him with either ability on. 

I would also replace Hit Man with 98 OVR Debo (Deion Jones; MLB). He gets the same Avalanche X-Factor that Hit Man gets, and looks like a better overall User/SubLB to me. He looks like a perfect fit for those that run a 3-4 Defensive Formation in game.

My Rankings:

1. 98 OVR Gus The Bus (Gus Edwards; HB)

2. 98 OVR Flash (Cordarrelle Patterson; HB)

3. 98 OVR Groot (Greg Rousseau; LE)

4. 98 OVR Furious George (George Karlaftis; LE)

5. 98 OVR Maniac (Shaquille Leonard; LOLB)

6. 96 OVR Quadfather (A.J. Dillon; HB)

7. 96 OVR Red Tornado (Ryan Jensen; C)

8. 98 OVR Debo (Deion Jones; MLB)

9. 98 OVR Legatron (Greg Zurrlein; K)

10. 97 OVR The Terror (Terron Armstead; LT)

Do you agree or disagree with MUT.GG’s rankings of the Top 10 AKA New Class Players In Madden 23?

I would totally vote if i had any coins and had an experience with literally any of them

flash is number 1 imo and manic is proabbly 3

MrAgentSochi said:

Starting a new weekly thread series. The MUT.GG staff releases a Top 10 Player Item Rankings every Friday. Each week we’ll look at each list and members of the community and myself will state whether they agree or disagree with the list (I doubt many would rank them the exact same way but you never know), and what we would change (if we would change anything).

MUT.GG’s Rankings:

1. 98 OVR Gus The Bus (Gus Edwards; HB)

2. 98 OVR Flash (Cordarrelle Patterson; HB)

3. 96 OVR Quadfather (A.J. Dillon; HB)

4. 98 OVR Groot (Greg Rousseau; LE)

5. 98 OVR Furious George (George Karlaftis; LE)

6. 98 OVR Maniac (Shaquille Leonard; LOLB)

7. 96 OVR Red Tornado (Ryan Jensen; C)

8. 97 OVR Hit Man (Harrison Smith; SS)

9. 98 OVR Legatron (Greg Zurrlein; K)

10. 97 OVR The Terror (Terron Armstead; LT)

Agree Or Disagree?:

Disagree

What I Would Change:

In my opinion, this is one of the better rankings we have seen so far, but there are some things that I would change. 

First off, I would move Quadfather down to six, while moving Groot, Furious George, and Maniac up one spot each. Although he was completely broken when he first came out, he is no where near that level now. He can easily be stopped with the right defensive formations, and if you have players that can equip Secure Tackler or Tackle Supreme, they will have a much better chance of stopping him with either ability on. 

I would also replace Hit Man with 98 OVR Debo (Deion Jones; MLB). He gets the same Avalanche X-Factor that Hit Man gets, and looks like a better overall User/SubLB to me. He looks like a perfect fit for those that run a 3-4 Defensive Formation in game.

My Rankings:

1. 98 OVR Gus The Bus (Gus Edwards; HB)

2. 98 OVR Flash (Cordarrelle Patterson; HB)

3. 98 OVR Groot (Greg Rousseau; LE)

4. 98 OVR Furious George (George Karlaftis; LE)

5. 98 OVR Maniac (Shaquille Leonard; LOLB)

6. 96 OVR Quadfather (A.J. Dillon; HB)

7. 96 OVR Red Tornado (Ryan Jensen; C)

8. 98 OVR Debo (Deion Jones; MLB)

9. 98 OVR Legatron (Greg Zurrlein; K)

10. 97 OVR The Terror (Terron Armstead; LT)

Do you agree or disagree with MUT.GG’s rankings of the Top 10 AKA New Class Players In Madden 23?

Here's what I would change:

George is the only unstoppable force that’s 5 on 3 off, all the others are 5 on 5 off (besides milkman who's yards based).as well Groot doesn’t hit the FMV threshold which wouldn’t be a problem if he didn’t have the trait but he does. Flash is just better than Gus unless your going to run every play, they break basically the same amount of tackles and Phenom works after the catch as well which is huge as this really is a pass driven game. Flash is the better HB for 90% of people’s offensive schemes. I also agree Quad is too high. Debo is worse than Hitman because you can't run pick artist and lurker for 0ap, and I'm not going to spend 2ap on my linebacker. Also everyone is sleeping on universal coverage, its crazy good and imo Rhodes is the best of the 4 CB's who have it. Warden also is a good choice.

Here's my list:

1. Flash

2. Gus

3. George

4. Maniac

5. Groot

6. Rhodes/Warden

7. Milkman

8. Tornado

9. Quad

10. Hitman

How is Tank not on this list.  He is easily the best of the DE's in the game.

whiplash13 said:

How is Tank not on this list.  He is easily the best of the DE's in the game.

I share this feeling. Maybe it’s because he doesn’t get any top tier 0AP abilities?

whiplash13 said:

How is Tank not on this list.  He is easily the best of the DE's in the game.

I feel like it might be price, because TVPS weren’t around for Tank if I remember so he’s pretty rare. For example, I think Tank plays much, much better than Maniac but Tank is over a million coins while you could get Maniac free from the challenges with the same X factor. Still agree Tank is much better in game though.