Caleb Williams is a bust....

Last Post
Posts: 442 |
805
#1

Just telling you guys now. 

He isnt a leader...

I scout players all year.....

He doesn't have the personality of a top QB. Kyler Murray Redux.....

Aside from my madden playing.....I watch film and I love the NFL draft.

Maybe you don't agree....but I am telling you the kid is a bust. Won't ever be a top QB. I can see it in his eyes when he talks. He isnt a winner. He isnt a top QB.

He maybe can be Jalen Hurts/Kyle Murray....?...Geno Smith? Zak Wilson ?....but not number one material. 

He isnt Mahomes.

His personality is an issue. Big issue.

Caleb Williams isn't comfortable in his own skin.....easy to see.

And he is supposed to put a whole team and city on his back?

Ok...

He is a side-show.....

Remember this post.....

Last edited by Surgical0ffense - , edited 13 times in total.
Reply with quote Send DM Report
Posts: 293 |
950
#2

yeah he’s got bust written all over him. he may have the physical abilities but everything else about him is not NFL material.

Reply with quote Send DM Report
Posts: 1355 |
5
#3

As a Bears fan I am not excited about drafting him.  He has so many red flags that a lot of people seem to overlook.  He holds onto the ball as long or longer than Fields does.  He won’t be able to extend plays like he did in college against much better competition in the NFL.  He fumbles way too much, and that should increase getting hit by bigger, stronger, and faster opponents.  He struggled against better opponents in College.  His backup came in and threw 6 tds in USC’s bowl game, which makes you wonder how good is he vs how good is the system at USC.

Reply with quote Send DM Report
Posts: 408 |
5,140
#4
Surgical0ffense said:

Just telling you guys now. 

He isnt a leader...

I scout players all year.....

He doesn't have the personality of a top QB. Kyler Murray Redux.....

Aside from my madden playing.....I watch film and I love the NFL draft.

Maybe you don't agree....but I am telling you the kid is a bust. Won't ever be a top QB. I can see it in his eyes when he talks. He isnt a winner. He isnt a top QB.

He maybe can be Jalen Hurts/Kyle Murray....?...Geno Smith? Zak Wilson ?....but not number one material. 

He isnt Mahomes.

His personality is an issue. Big issue.

Caleb Williams isn't comfortable in his own skin.....easy to see.

And he is supposed to put a whole team and city on his back?

Ok...

He is a side-show.....

Remember this post.....

if you think about it USC has only produced one decent quarterback in the last 30 years, Carson Palmer. All the rest were failures. And I can tell you as a  Jets fan, nobody is worse than Zach Wilson.

Last edited by Daytripper517 - , edited 1 time in total.
Reply with quote Send DM Report
Posts: 1002 |
3,115
#5

at the very worst, he'll still be the best QB in bears history

Reply with quote Send DM Report
Posts: 18 |
50
#6

As a Pats fan I felt the same about Mac Jones right away, albeit nobody ever considered him #1 overall material.  Something about his body language and the shakiness in his voice

Reply with quote Send DM Report
Posts: 580 |
427
#7

As a Sooner fan, and one who was very upset when Caleb followed Lincoln Riley to USC, I do watch every single OU game. When he was on the field at OU, I can tell you he has generational talent. Some of the things he can do on the field will leave you dumbfounded. I would lean easily towards him being a top tier QB for a very long time, and this is coming from someone who wanted him to fail soo bad (because he left OU).. If he ends up being a bust in the NFL, which I think is highly unlikely, it will be because of his emotional state, which in my opinion is the only Crack in his armour.

Last edited by Mokascloud - , edited 1 time in total.
Reply with quote Send DM Report
Posts: 1002 |
3,115
#8
MaddenDew said:

As a Pats fan I felt the same about Mac Jones right away, albeit nobody ever considered him #1 overall material.  Something about his body language and the shakiness in his voice

Majority of the league felt the same way about Mac Jones. Nick Saban's 2020 covid ring got a lot of mediocre players drafted.

Reply with quote Send DM Report
Posts: 2168 |
1,198
#9

Hey! Don’t you dare speak about my 🐐 like that!!! His personality is just fine he’s just overhated. I don’t get the Murray slander ya some FORMER players have shit on him but those like pat pete are just angry they ain’t on the team no more. 

Also I agree Caleb has bust written all over him. I’d compare him to Ryan Leaf situation, not talent wise his is better than Leaf’s but his attitude seems childish and spoiled like Leaf. I hope his nfl trajectory isn’t that way but I’m just glad the cardinals have a franchise QB and can sit back and just draft him some weapons.

Reply with quote Send DM Report
Posts: 179 |
0
#10
Surgical0ffense said:

Just telling you guys now. 

He isnt a leader...

I scout players all year.....

He doesn't have the personality of a top QB. Kyler Murray Redux.....

Aside from my madden playing.....I watch film and I love the NFL draft.

Maybe you don't agree....but I am telling you the kid is a bust. Won't ever be a top QB. I can see it in his eyes when he talks. He isnt a winner. He isnt a top QB.

He maybe can be Jalen Hurts/Kyle Murray....?...Geno Smith? Zak Wilson ?....but not number one material. 

He isnt Mahomes.

His personality is an issue. Big issue.

Caleb Williams isn't comfortable in his own skin.....easy to see.

And he is supposed to put a whole team and city on his back?

Ok...

He is a side-show.....

Remember this post.....

And his nails

Reply with quote Send DM Report
Posts: 179 |
0
#11
AZCARDS said:

Hey! Don’t you dare speak about my 🐐 like that!!! His personality is just fine he’s just overhated. I don’t get the Murray slander ya some FORMER players have shit on him but those like pat pete are just angry they ain’t on the team no more. 

Also I agree Caleb has bust written all over him. I’d compare him to Ryan Leaf situation, not talent wise his is better than Leaf’s but his attitude seems childish and spoiled like Leaf. I hope his nfl trajectory isn’t that way but I’m just glad the cardinals have a franchise QB and can sit back and just draft him some weapons.

Yes everyone who plays cod is a leader

Reply with quote Send DM Report
Posts: 179 |
0
#12
AZCARDS said:

Hey! Don’t you dare speak about my 🐐 like that!!! His personality is just fine he’s just overhated. I don’t get the Murray slander ya some FORMER players have shit on him but those like pat pete are just angry they ain’t on the team no more. 

Also I agree Caleb has bust written all over him. I’d compare him to Ryan Leaf situation, not talent wise his is better than Leaf’s but his attitude seems childish and spoiled like Leaf. I hope his nfl trajectory isn’t that way but I’m just glad the cardinals have a franchise QB and can sit back and just draft him some weapons.

Not being sarcastic

Reply with quote Send DM Report
Posts: 602 |
200
#13

Just here to thank the Bears for letting us rob them in broad daylight!! 🙏

Reply with quote Send DM Report
Posts: 802 |
2,045
#14

Happy with this as a packers fan; although I’ll miss Justin fields he was so horrible

Reply with quote Send DM Report
Posts: 802 |
2,045
#15
Saph said:

Just here to thank the Bears for letting us rob them in broad daylight!! 🙏

Trust me as a packers fan, you shouldn’t be happy with him 😭

Reply with quote Send DM Report
Log in to join the conversation