Personally, I would make either Deon Jackson, or Aidan Hutchinson. I don't know if anyone else used that 89 OVR Deon Jackson when he first came out, but he broke so many tackles for me and had around 4k rushing yards over like 50 games. He played like he had built-in freight train activated all the time. When Hutch came out, in my opinion he was one of the best pass rushers in the game. He was getting pressure every play and playing on an Aaron Donald level. He is still pretty decent today, but is quickly getting outdated, so I would love to see a Hutch upgrade sometime.
(completely unrelated) Where the heck is Jonathan Taylor's upgrade?