Is Fields really that much better than Vick with his abilities?

Comparing them it seems he is (better at literally everything except ballcarrier moves like juke, spin and carry, ESPECIALLY CARRY WOW lol) plus the bonus for some myself included of being right handed, but I had the same question myself and have seen others ask and a surprising amount of people seem to actually PREFER/go back to Vick? 

Im asking bc ive been using Vick forever now and pretty happy with him for now but a slight upgrade is always nice and im only a couple rewards away. 

PS: how do so many people have him/had him since friday? Ive done damn near everything but all the sets (still did some of those even) and im STILL  like 80 competitive XP away from getting him apparently. Smh

i think you will like him better than Vick. Vick makes funky throws imo on certain routes. Fields just gets the ball there to me. Try him out and see how he feels.

Honestly, this is one of those questions where you're the only one who can truly answer it. The large difference in carrying means you should be more conservative when running with Fields. Which can be a huge negative depending on your playstyle. Other than that they're very similar cards especially if you use gunslinger.

In my sample of two h2h games, Fields has played well for me. Well enough that I'd only replace him with a QB with better abilities.

Hope you give Fields a shot to be your qb1.

I didn’t like Fields got him on Friday and went back to Vick only played two games with him though he threw a wild pass not under pressure in the second game that was picked  and it pissed me off so maybe I didn’t give him a fair shake

I got # 524 today and tried him out in a few h2h games and i was very surprised with his release thanks to gunslinger.He zips the ball in the tiniest placec for the most part but he did sail a few passes .

Never used Vick.  Fields is fine as a passer and has decent speed.  With the 53 carrying, he fumbles EVERY time you run if you don’t slide or get out of bounds.  If someone breathes on him while out of the pocket, he fumbles.  That’s the biggest issue I’ve seen.

Charmingjmor said:

Never used Vick.  Fields is fine as a passer and has decent speed.  With the 53 carrying, he fumbles EVERY time you run if you don’t slide or get out of bounds.  If someone breathes on him while out of the pocket, he fumbles.  That’s the biggest issue I’ve seen.

Decent speed? Bruh he’s faster than most wide receivers 😂😂

Vick > Fields

"Is Fields really that much better than Vick with his abilities?"...no.

phillyphilly said:

Decent speed? Bruh he’s faster than most wide receivers 😂😂

Doesn’t do much good when he drops the ball

Droopy34 said:

i think you will like him better than Vick. Vick makes funky throws imo on certain routes. Fields just gets the ball there to me. Try him out and see how he feels.

See how he Fields.

Fields misses so many throws.  I’ll stick with him because he is free, but some of them are just silly. That is the case with all the QBs this year.

Vick plays way better

LeftHandUp said:

See how he Fields.

Bravo 👏🏽