[POLL] how would YOU rate yourself on your madden skill?

There should be more objective ways to determine this, like win rate or something. Elo obviously comes into play but win rate should paint a decent picture. Probably some other stuff too like giveaways/takeaways.

3-5 depending on the night lmao

I rated myself a 5. I have always played on PS4 and did just fine in H2H’s winning around 70% of my games or so and beating many of the top 100 players even though I never play enough games to get ranked that high.

Last week I finally bought a PS5 and just started playing 24 so I’m learning how insanely different the game is on current gen. So far I’ve won about 50% of my H2H games but I’m still trying to get a good team built to try to compete.

I'm ass but at least I don't run rpos and dollar. I use eagles playbooks.

EazyBreezy said:

For me I’d honestly give it a 7, I’m in legend division and I can make budget players(I still have the 2 combine 93 receivers as my 2 and 3rd receiver) 

but if someone knows how to beat my scheme I can’t stop them. 
 

how about you?

Great detailed community poll, with excellent (and numerous) options.  I'm right there with you, probably rate myself as a "7" although my gameplay can be wildly inconsistent at times, especially on offense if / when i fail to protect the ball.  I dropped out of Legend tier just recently, can't really bring myself to play more than a couple/few H2H games lately.  Holding out hope for some type of Theme Team Remix promo to keep me interested, but after attempting to convert to my full 50/50 49ers squad, it's still feeling ridiculously gimped when directly compared with my 70/70 SB hybrid TT (also 25/50 Niners, 6/6 AKA Crews "Y2K" & 15/60 Combine).

I think i went 10-4 in MUT Champs last week... not playing much (if any) this week, my Comp Pass is done, i need a brief break to determine if i'm gonna sign up for more pain and suffering with Season 6.  I guess i'm currently 2-0 or maybe 3-0 in MUT Champs, but one dude quit on me last evening.  Almost certainly did me a favor.

6 here...i win about 60% of my h2h matchups.

TecmoEagles said:

23% of players here claim to be Legends-MCS pro Level, yet according to the stats only 1% of folks are at Legends.

Ya but 1% of the entire madden community is way more than 23% of the mut gg community. The people on here are clearly more invested in madden than others

Somewhere between 6 and 7. I tend to bounce between legend and mvp

Good, not great. If someone is a massive cheeser I bail, I don’t want to have to do a million audibles before every play.  I generally run dime w 4 98 cbs and hope someone passes enough they make mistakes.  On off I think I’m a pretty good play caller so if I run about 30 off plays a game I’d say there’s 20-25 diff calls in there to set things up

legend division and 10+ super bowls in that division, the stats don’t work for all madden for some reason but i know this as i saved up 6 lots of 5x trophy packs and ended up getting trash around 95 over all drops 🤣🤣 and i’ve won others when i just opened them day of

i say I’m pretty decent but i can’t beat some of the best MCS E book followers. probably a 50/50 match up in those games.  some of them bunch rpo schemes are cooked man, end up rage quitting in half those matches especially now as it’s the end of the year and I’m less likely to want to sweat it out at this point of the game

Five. But I have been throwing a lot picks. Hard to know how good I am when I frequently get RNG’d, and am not making up for it with abusive schemes.

I’m top 20 consistently in mut champs whenever I try so I think I’m pretty good😭