I made a whole lineup of players with nicknames: https://www.mut.gg/23/lineup-builder/11c243bb-a3a8-41cc-a51c-a9cb4558b64c/
Credit to Wikipedia for helping: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ListofNFL_nicknames
Check it out, tell me your thoughts, or tell me anything I missed.
(EDIT: I'm not using players who are out of position, for example, even though Derrick Henry, aka King Henry, has a 99 OOP card, I won't be using it on the team.)
Lamar Jackson: Action Jackson
Josh Allen: Mr January
Chad Johnson: Chad Ochocino
Demaryius Thomas: DT
Larry Fitzgerald: Larry Legend
Calvin Johnson: Megatron
Justin Jefferson: JJettas
Lesean Mccoy: Shady
Ladainian Tomlinson: LDT
Walter Payton: Sweetness
Orlando Pace: Pancake Man
Trent Williams: Silverback
Ryan Jensen: Red Tornado
Mike Ditka: Iron MikeĀ
Rob Gronkowski: Gronk
Travis Kelce: Zeus
Ed Reed: Ball Hawk
Eddie Jackson: BoJack
Lawrence Taylor: LT
Za'Darius Smith and Preston Smith: Smith Bros
Deion Jones: Debo
Ray Lewis: Brick Wall
Malcolm Rodriguez: Rodrigo
Ray Nitschke: Wildman
Joey Bosa and Nick Bosa: Big Bear and Smaller Bear
Ted Hendricks: The Mad Stork
Troy Polamalu: The Samoan Headhunter
Kam Chancellor: Bam Bam Kam
Darrelle Revis: Revis Island
Dick Lane: Night Train Lane
Darius Slay: Big Play Slay
Deion Sanders: Prime Time
Janoris Jenkins: Jackrabbit
Aaron Donald: The Terminator
Reggie White: The Minister of Defense
George Karlaftis: Furious George
Dexter Lawrence: Sexy Dexy
William Perry: The Refrigerator
Joe Greene: Mean Joe Greene
Javon Hargrave: Gravedigger
Jamie Gillian: The Scottish Hammer
Greg Zuerlein: Greg The Leg, Legatron