Top QB's? Bad QB's? Other tips on QB's

So for the past 3-6 weeks I've been trying every QB that is at least 93ovr or higher. Some QBs have solid considerations for top QB or for specific offensive schemes.

But my final conclusion is Elway is by far the best. I came to this conclusion after finally pulling the trigger on getting him yesterday. He gives me perfect passing on I'd say 97-99% of my passes. I could count on one hand the amount of errant passes I've had. He's strong in the pocket, fast enough to roll out for pass and sneakily fast enough to scramble for few yards here and there. He'll never be a scramble first option but he can easily get me ~50yds on 4-6 scrambles. I run on him: Run & Gun, SFL, HRM and Fearless. 40/40 Legends TT and Legendary Let It Rip.

Other QBs I think in conversation for top are: Scrambler Brady, Harvest Rodgers, Comp Fitzpatrick

Some overrated QBs: Cunningham (weak abilites), Mahomes (Slinger 2 can be issues & good but not great abilities), Bledsoe (consistently inconsistent)

Top QBs per Category
Pocket Passer: Elway, Brady, Bledsoe
Balance: Elway, Brady, Fitzpatrick, Tua
Scrambler: Cunningham, Newton, Fields, RGIII
Discount/NMS options: Geno, Brady (AKA), Willis, Goff, Jones

Avoidables/Non Preferences
Young, Vick, Warner, Hurts, Cunningham

Any comments, suggestions, tips or further conversation to help the community or tell me why I'm wrong is appreciated. I like helping others in the community. If there's something I'm missing or misunderstanding, please feel free to tell me.

I think having a qb with at least 85 speed is kind of needed now. When I used elway, it was so hard to face opponents with man blitzes, and i had to take 5 sacks a game pretty much. I feel like Bledsoe is the best in the game rn, but thats just my preference. Cunningham isnt avoidable id say, hes prolly a top 3 qb, and feels solid powered up.

mostly agree

buuut cunningham for me balls out i feel like he just is the best all around qb (cuz elway is slow)

i give elway a 1a and cunningham a 1b

NotLandon33 said:

I think having a qb with at least 85 speed is kind of needed now. When I used elway, it was so hard to face opponents with man blitzes, and i had to take 5 sacks a game pretty much. I feel like Bledsoe is the best in the game rn, but thats just my preference. Cunningham isnt avoidable id say, hes prolly a top 3 qb, and feels solid powered up.

understandable, idk your o-line situation. I hear alot of good for Cunningham but I've also heard and felt myself that he seems clunky. Bledsoe either seems to be the best or the worst for me. So depends on consistenty of him for you.

LLLAAAAMMMMMAAAARRRR said:

mostly agree

buuut cunningham for me balls out i feel like he just is the best all around qb (cuz elway is slow)

i give elway a 1a and cunningham a 1b

I feel you, Cunningham just felt clunky to me but ik some people love him. If you pocket passer, Elway. If you want more movement or do lots of option, then Cunningham for sure.

DigestedRaptor6 said:

I feel you, Cunningham just felt clunky to me but ik some people love him. If you pocket passer, Elway. If you want more movement or do lots of option, then Cunningham for sure.

great post btw

LLLAAAAMMMMMAAAARRRR said:

great post btw

Much appreciated, I just wanted to get a more vivid feel of the QB Market atm. Hopefully people can use this for the mean time and get an updated post in the next few months once a plentiful batch of new QBs come out.

Great break dow! I agree with pretty much everything. Legend cards are often overrated because it costs hundreds of thousands of coins to get good abilities which run the game. Rodgers is also an amazing budget beast, I had him till Christmas when I got Brady.

SebSeb88 said:

Great break dow! I agree with pretty much everything. Legend cards are often overrated because it costs hundreds of thousands of coins to get good abilities which run the game. Rodgers is also an amazing budget beast, I had him till Christmas when I got Brady.

That's my gripe with legends this year. Especially when said legend has ok to just piss poor abilities.

Blitz Vick on a 50/50 Steelers TT with the Leg strat for steelers and let it rip is unfair. He is stupidly broken with 96 Speed and great throwing stats

you gotta add 93 rodgers in the NMS discussion, he is by far the better than anyone one the list you had. he honestly played better in the pocket for me than Bledsoe

SteelersFan19 said:

Blitz Vick on a 50/50 Steelers TT with the Leg strat for steelers and let it rip is unfair. He is stupidly broken with 96 Speed and great throwing stats

This kind of information is helpful, good to know. Thanks

IAMthesauce14 said:

you gotta add 93 rodgers in the NMS discussion, he is by far the better than anyone one the list you had. he honestly played better in the pocket for me than Bledsoe

All but one of my NMS options are free from challenges. Brady from AKA BND Pack. Goff and Jones from ZC Challenges/Season Pass. Willis from Ghost of MUT challenges. Geno is really cheap in AH. Rodgers can be a speedy price for some NMS teams.

I've used the best versions of Cunningham, Fitz, McNabb, Tua, Brady, Rodgers, Hurtz, Vick & Elway in a constant search for that perfect QB for my play style...

I never thought Drew would be the answer but I honestly think he works the best for the cost and best AP ability layout.

Don't think I'll be getting rid of Bledsoe anytime soon