Which is the better WR?

Last Post

Which is the better WR?

Harold Carmichael
35%
Calvin Johnson
45%
Brandon Marshall
0%
Plaxico Burress
0%
Tyreek Hill
20%
Total votes: 20
Posts: 64 |
2,015
#1

Of the 5, which is the better WR: Harold Carmichael, Calvin Johnson, Brandon Marshall, Plaxico Burress or Tyreek Hill?

Last edited by KingBalakay - , edited 2 times in total.
Reply with quote Send DM Report
Posts: 10298 |
5,651
#2

Everyone there is over 6'5 except for Hill. His 2 points of speed arent worth that. 

If youre just gonna high point, any one of them will work. If you want a sort of run blocker wr, then Bmarsh or Megatron is your man. 

Cheapest is going to be Carmichael and/or you could get 3 90s for him.

Personally, Id take Megatron.

Last edited by kaotikords - , edited 2 times in total.
Reply with quote Send DM Report
Posts: 23 |
50
#3

I think its tough to compare all 5 of those.. 4 are big body receivers, then you have the speedy, excellent route running, tyreek... you would want tyreek to do different things on the field.. so here are my thoughts on the big boys and the order i would choose them (all things considered):

Carmichael.... Super Tall, 1 AP Deep Out Elite  250k

Megatron... Tall, 1 AP Deep Out Elite  400k

Plaxico... Pretty much a cheaper Megatron 321k

Marshall... Tall, Drops Open Passes Yes (oof) 400k

*Theme teams could heavily effect this order!*

Reply with quote Send DM Report
Posts: 969 |
540
#4

im gonna say megatron

Reply with quote Send DM Report
Posts: 2357 |
125
#5

Hard to deny that height, i voted carmichael

Reply with quote Send DM Report
Log in to join the conversation