The qb rankings j came out, and it’s horrendous. I mean jalen hurts, who finished 2nd in mvp voting is only an 88? Daniel jones had a good year, an 75? All the reason why I’m not getting Madden 24 for myself
dantheman1218
Posts: 59 |
22
Last edited by
dantheman1218
- ,
edited 1
time in total.
kaotikords
Posts: 10298 |
5,551
Outside the top QBs yeah they all seem pretty bad.
Pickett is 73 and had one of the best starts for a QB ever
Stlrdogs7
Posts: 327 |
1,096
Lamar is not better than Hurts. And Pickett should be higher. That’s all I’ve got to say.
goneviralbop
Posts: 181 |
2,445
dantheman1218 said:The qb rankings j came out, and it’s horrendous. I mean jalen hurts, who finished 2nd in mvp voting is only an 88? Daniel jones had a good year, an 75? All the reason why I’m not getting Madden 24 for myself
It does seem like they didn't consider 2023 much at all for some players. Lamar and Dak remain high, while Tua and Hurts didn't get credit for what they did. It's weird.
GForce
Posts: 530 |
124
Christian Watson has a 77. Let that sink in. I saw on Twitter a list of people better than him: Marvin Jones, MVS, Kendrick Bourne, Josh Palmer, and Rookie Jaxon Smith-Njigba. Micheal Gallup is an 81 for crying out loud! You can’t debate Gallup is 4 ovr better. It’s crazy. I also think ARod has a low rating but I’m biased but still, he just had one bad season. Bakhtiari is really low, he’s at least a 95 fully healthy. I also think for being the cover athlete Josh Allen should’ve been higher. At least a 95 or 96. I don’t think anyone would’ve fought EA if they put him at 97 even
BearJordan23
Posts: 326 |
2
Justin fields is a 76??? He’s the same overall as tanehill. I also wil not be purchasing madden 24 for this reason
Amungusbeest
Posts: 2990 |
1,698
Geno Smith at 81 is awesome!
kaotikords
Posts: 10298 |
5,551
Amungusbeest said:Geno Smith at 81 is awesome!
Should be much higher
Amungusbeest
Posts: 2990 |
1,698
kaotikords said:Should be much higher
yeah but compared to the other QB’s ( Daniel Jones cough cough) he’s good
Justin_Time18
Posts: 2080 |
0
kaotikords said:Outside the top QBs yeah they all seem pretty bad.
Pickett is 73 and had one of the best starts for a QB ever
😂
Justin_Time18
Posts: 2080 |
0
BearJordan23 said:Justin fields is a 76??? He’s the same overall as tanehill. I also wil not be purchasing madden 24 for this reason
Well he’s kinda mid
QB283
Posts: 5595 |
1
They gave Stetson Bennett IV 63 juke move. For those of you who know.... this rating is disrespectful.
dantheman1218
Posts: 59 |
22
I’m not gonna lie, tua deserves to be higher IF he stays healthy. If not, I’m fine where he is. But overall, I think jaylen waddle at 88 is disrespectful. Dude almost had as many yards as AJ brown is is crazy
goneviralbop
Posts: 181 |
2,445
dantheman1218 said:I’m not gonna lie, tua deserves to be higher IF he stays healthy. If not, I’m fine where he is. But overall, I think jaylen waddle at 88 is disrespectful. Dude almost had as many yards as AJ brown is is crazy
Yeah, that one bugged me as well. He's already right there with Hill after two seasons.
goneviralbop
Posts: 181 |
2,445
Here's the one that bugs me.
Kenny Walker III: 228 rushes for 1,050 yards (4.6 yards per carry) and 9 TDs, along with 165 receiving yards (6.1 YPC) and 0 TDs. PFF grades him at 76.7 overall, with a split of 83.5 rushing and 56.0 receiving.
Tyler Allgeier: 210 rushes for 1,305 yards (4.9 yards per carry) and 3 TDs, along with 139 receiving yards (8.7 YPC) and 1 TD. PFF grades him 86.7 overall, with a split of 88.0 rushing and 61.6 receiving.
Walker gets an 87, while Allgeier gets a 78.
You're only doing those grades with that massive a gap because Walker got drafted higher. Period.
(Breece Hall got jobbed, too, but that's because he missed more than half the season.)
Log in to join the conversation