Would you completely get rid of abilities in madden 24?

yes, but it will never happen

yes

theoriginalkbgames33 said:

yes and no.

what’s the no

yes. that’s all there is to it. yes.

Yes X factors ruined the game! 
They were EA’s answer to create parity! And MOST IMPORTANTLY making  madden even more of a Cash Cow 🐮!

Because when mut first started and players played to stats everyone would grab same players and ultimately have same teams! Which sometimes did suck! 
But the X factor monster EA created has taken a life of its own. 
Ruining the game by default! Creating less competitive games!!  
It also created us witnessing people making an out right mockery of the game using a punter to win the madden bowl! 
Thus making Madden not a real stimulation football game! 
BEFORE MUT When people use to just pick a team and go games were more fun and you spent more time playing the games!

Not rerolling eggs 🥚, Christmas Stocking, and basically playing the game like I’m at the casino 🎰 playing slots on a heater!

MUT IS THE TRUE BLAME IT CREATED TRUE FANTASY FOOTBALL! Now no one cares that players are getting cards 🃏 that never even supported what they did in real life nor abilites they never had as long as their team and player gets it!   Meanwhile none of this is making people play the ACTUAL game more! Or better skill wise  just dependent on X Factors and reading trying to keep up with it all 😂

Yes

Yes, aside from DZKO. It’s literally the only way to stop people from spamming streaks to Moss and aggs all game long

Please dump abilities... but 1st fix game logic and player interactions... the interactions are so flawed EA... I would love to truly speak to somebody on the committee...

Linebackers shouldn't need lurker to jump but I do agree every linebacker isn't jumping out the building...

Wrs shouldn't need route tech to properly cut and beat coverage but I agree 1 single route should not beat a coverage 100% ...

Cbs shouldn't need ko's... it should be well timed user swats or pass break ups if the reciever hasn't caught the ball flush...

Qbs shouldn't need pass lead elite or set feet lead to throw routes n not be undercut....

I can honestly go on n on... Though i have only owned EVERY MADDEN since 95, I have been playin madden since the beginning...  

I understand makin a product for people who have less time to put into the game but u have to reward the people who may use their free time to play this game competitively.... I DO NOT SPEAK for everybody but this madden really hurt the franchise in my eyes and I know yall are makin alotta money, but all I ask is that u remember the guys that backed yall wen there was other options...

I just say bring Power-Ups back. The fun is bulding the card up to It's max level.

Yes Xfactors and ko are bs

TheRealAkdigger said:

what’s the no

I basically said this

and scroll down towards my name. to add on to that play action would be horribly coded to where disengages would be even more talked about on this site, and I reference that a few times on this site.

but the TL;DR is yes keep the abilities on non-skill positions besides quarterback, offensive lineman, defensive lineman and linebackers  and no cause certain plays won't work because it requires time and the choices of quarterback would be brain-dead (Vick,lamar,rg3)

I like abilities but do feel it needs to be limited heavily. Maybe something along the lines of you can only give abilities to your 3 x-factor players. Make people strategically put their abilities in positions that benefit their play style. It would also make changing abilities at half time way more useful and strategic.

QB283 said:

Yes. They need to program it like real football. A couple points I'd like to make:

1. QBs shouldn't need SFL/PLE in order to be usable. Just program the card so it plays like an NFL QB. They should play as if they have these abilities anyway. As for something like Gunslinger, it shouldn't be necessary.

2. Organic pass rush. No abilities. Shouldn't need ET and DON in order to generate pressure. Pressure should be determined by 1 on 1 matchups and personnel. If I'm blitzing 8 players then I should get pressure but WRs should be wide open. If I rush only 3 or 4 the amount of pressure should be lower, except in the case where an edge rusher is not double teamed and is vastly superior in ratings to the lineman.

Couldnt have said it better myself

No but the aka X factors gotta go. Abilitys are a good part of madden. The archatypes of man and zone buckets and the abilitys they get from stats and the gt buckets are a big part of madden so those should stay but the AKA X FACTORS broke the game